Cincy Jungle: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





Questioning Marvin Lewis

There are those that are questioning if Marvin Lewis can get the Bengals over that hump. Enough of these 8-8 seasons; let's win a playoff game. Yes, he's led one of the most dramatic team turn-arounds (second to Sean Payton's Saints) in memorable history before taking a step backwards after an 11-5 season. His game management is questioned. His half-time adjustments -- if there's any -- are criticized. His ability to squash potential off-the-field issues unimpressive.

You can even criticize his draft choices.

Of the only players drafted in 2003, only Eric Steinbach, Carson Palmer and Jeremi Johnson start. Kelley Washington has been a disappointment and Scott Kooistra is fifth player still on the team. Of the 2004 draft choices, Landon Johnson, Madieu Williams and Robert Geathers have consistently made it on the field. Chris Perry is nothing but a broken (bone) record and Keiwan Ratliff keeps falling in the depth charts. Caleb Miller, while having a great 2006 by his standards, has been a primarily special teams player. Of the players drafted in 2005, only Eric Ghiaciuc and David Pollack started. Thurman is likely gone, Henry will never break a two-WR starting lineup and Adam Kieft has been injured since being drafted. The 2006 draft was a good one -- through the first two rounds. Then Rucker, Nicholson and McNeal have existing legal issues. Peko has shown flashes of being a good defensive tackle and Ethan Kilmer is the best special teams player on the team.

It's true; drafting in the NFL is nothing more than a crap-shoot. You pick guys and hope for quality production and guys that understand responsibility to their communities. In Lewis' defense, most of the guys that have gotten arrested either had no history of issues, or things happened while they were not under Bengals employment. And realistically, Lewis has picked up some great guys -- obviously. Some guys get lucky drafting players; others don't. Marvin is about in the middle.

More on questioning Marvin Lewis...

It drives me nuts when teams call a timeout to prevent a 5-yard delay of game penalty.

"Under no circumstances is anyone but the head coach to use a timeout," Fisher said. "There are a lot of considerations. Are you better off taking a delay-of-game penalty on third-and-1 and going to third-and-6 than using a timeout early in a game? Does it make sense to challenge a spot on third down early in the game and risk losing a timeout?"

Lewis, as Mark Curnutte writes, allows his assistants to decide these things.

Cincinnati's Lewis relies on his assistant coaches - especially special-teams coach Darrin Simmons, who is on the sideline with Lewis and does not wear a headset. Simmons constantly reminds Lewis of game time, timeouts and challenges remaining, though Lewis said he also keeps track of such details in his head.

Curnutte gives us a perfect example as to why people are questioning Lewis' game management decisions.

...icing Reed left Lewis with just one timeout for his offense. The Bengals moved 46 yards to the Pittsburgh 21-yard line, and Cincinnati called its third and final timeout after quarterback Carson Palmer spiked the ball to stop the clock. Shayne Graham missed an attempt at a winning 39-yard field goal, the game went in to overtime, and the Steelers won 23-17.

Having another timeout would have allowed the Bengals to run another play or two. But Lewis said the fact that his team needed only a field goal to win allowed him to ice Reed.

Lewis has done nothing but provide a sense of pride with the fans. But sometimes we forget he's only a four-year head coach. And a head coach of an NFL team requires time with experience to develop a sound strategy in games. Look at some of the more established coaches: Jeff Fisher has coached 13 seasons; Mike Holmgren for 15 seasons; Mike Shanahan for 14 seasons. These guys have experience that Lewis does not. It will grow with time and hopefully, with the Cincinnati Bengals. Unrelated note: Tom Landry has 21 post season wins -- the all-time record.

More killer stats from Mark Curnutte that questions half-time adjustments. Here's the footnotes:

  • Bengals led opponents in the first half, 197-126. Bengals, in the second half, were outscored 205-176. If you take away the 42 points by the Chargers, the Bengals outscore their opponents 176-163.
  • Bengals were: 1-4 trailing at half-time, 2-6 trailing after three, 1-3 when points decided by three or less and 2-5 when points decided by seven or less. "In four seasons under Lewis, the Bengals are 6-20 when trailing at halftime and 5-24 when trailing after three quarters."

Decisions, decisions [Enquirer]
Would you make the call? [Enquirer]

0 recs | Comment 2 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

Marvin
So what do you think about Marvin?  Your post explores some of the criticisms swirling out there but I'm interested in your take.  

I agree that the last drive in regulation of the Pittsburgh game was mismanaged.  The timeouts could have been used to take a shot at the end zone and avoid the need for a game-winning field goal pressure situation.  

I dunno...Marvin has had to turn this team around from nothing, but three 8-8 seasons out of four isn't terrific.  Then again, the AFC has been so dominant this decade.  We could also point out that the Bengals haven't had a losing season in four years...a lot of teams would love to be able to claim that.  I think it's way too early to start seriously talking about replacing Marvin, but if the Bengals are still swiring in mediocrity two seasons from now things might be different.

The Curly R: Blogging the Redskins

by Brandon on Jan 21, 2007 1:48 PM EST   0 recs

RE:
I think that Marvin is a young head coach still understanding the intricacies of managing a football game. I think he's done a fabulous job turning this thing around. From rebuilt workout facilities to a culture that went from buddy, un-professional and egocentric attitudes to a team oriented-one-purpose attitude.

But to say that I'm not disappointed in how this team has devolved the past season would be a lie. I'm very disappointed. I could reach for at least 10 excuses on how this team lost -- none of which, I believe, are Marvin's fault. The team, at one point overcame adversity and looked to be the best Wild Card team. I contributed that to Marvin and keeping the team focused when things around them fell apart.  Then the team fell to adversity and poorly mismanaged games -- which I think is fair to point to Lewis.

I think 2006 was a step back. And I think 2007 will be a big year for Marvin. Will he remain around 8-8 or was 2006 truly an aberration? If the Bengals go 8-8 again, it could mean Lewis' job if the Bengals don't at least accomplish one post-season win. And I think the AFC North will be up for grabs.

But the bigger question is, do you trust ownership to find someone that would improve off Lewis' legacy here or will the Brown family go backwards... isn't that scary enough to keep Lewis? ;-)

by Kirkendall on Jan 21, 2007 2:52 PM EST to parent up   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Cincinnati Bengals.
Ad-medium-smq

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Fast_plane_bengal_small
Bengals Web Site?
Atari_small
Geather's cousin in New Orleans
Wimbley_small
Cool MMORPG footballgame
Pgf_small
Alexander to the Bengals?
Curtis_isaac_small
One from the invites...
Dsc_0113_small
Keith Rivers
Atari_small
Buzz Bissinger is FIRED up.
Fast_plane_bengal_small
No RB picks vs Defense
Fast_plane_bengal_small
Jason Shirley
Curtis_isaac_small
Jason Shirley- Manchild.

Post New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Ad-banner-faketeams
Site Meter