Cincy Jungle: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: The Boxing Bulletin for Boxing Fans!

I wonder... about the Bengals cut-down day

...why Ed Hartwell was cut.

If you're on a roster bubble, you better contribute to special teams. But I admit, I'm slightly surprised. With Rashad Jeanty most likely down against Baltimore, Ahmad Brooks slow (like a snail) development, Lemar Marshall just joining the team and Andre Frazier mostly a special teams guy, you'd think a healthy Hartwell would only benefit the team. It was even projected he'd start at the middle while Brooks went back to the development-club. But one consistency at linebacker, is that all six have played well, in one form or another, on special teams in the past year.

...if injury and disappointment gave Chatman a roster spot.

Another roster choice surprised me... at first. During the 2006 offseason, the Bengals signed Antonio Chatman to a two-year deal. Before coming to Cincinnati, Chatman played in 48 of a possible 48 games. During 2006, Chatman suffered a hamstring injury in a preseason game against the Packers and missed the first three regular season games. After playing three games (3 receptions for 22 yards), he reaggravated the injury and was placed on IR. This preseason, Chatman hasn't played preseason down and isn't expected to play in the opener against Baltimore.

It makes you wonder why Chatman was given a roster spot. Then you look at group of players that were cut at wide receiver. Bennie Brazell was often injured but didn't show up in preseason games either. Experience beat potential there. Reggie McNeal never adapted to the role and was one of the players arrested last year. He was also riding with Odell Thurman on the night of his DUI. Jesse Holley was the other.

Chris Henry leading the team in receptions and playing all those preseason games was evident of the team's lack of depth at receiver. Therefore, after quietly banging around ideas, you get the picture at why they kept Chatman.

...if you agree with points?

I understand that the team can only keep so many players. In fact, that's basic stuff I should know, right? I liked Xzavie Jackson. It might have simply been an issue of talent, but one thing Jackson had was an awesome motor.

I would have liked to have seen more from Earl Everett. And no, I'm not saying he shouldn't have been cut. He was one of my surprise picks to make the roster. I won't disclose the others. My credibility as a student of Nostradamus might take another hit after predicting Chris Henry would be suspension-free in 2007..

T.J. Wright had outstanding moments this preseason. Against the Colts, he picked off a Josh Betts pass and knocked down several passes. He was placed Injured waivers Saturday meaning if he clears waivers without an injury settlement, then he'll go on the Bengals IR. I missed most of Friday's game so I'm not sure of his exact injury. Hint, hint.

0 recs  |  Comment 3 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Hartwell
This is pure speculation on my part, but Hartwell suffered two injuries to his legs that required reconstruction: an Achilles tendon tear and a knee ligament.  Even though medical technology can do a good job repairing both of those injuries, he had two.  So it wouldn't surprise me if Hartwell had lost a step.  Lewis values speed; and a few years back, Lewis saw how fast the uninjured Hartwell was.  If the two injuries did take speed away from Hartwell, Lewis is the guy who'd see it most readily.  

My guess is that Hartwell survived this long because of his experience.  The Bengals Linebacker squad is notably short on experience, and Lewis wanted an older, more experienced player (like, perhaps, Brian Simmons?).  Then the team signed Lemar Marshall.  Marshall played a lot last night; presumably, Lewis and Hundley saw enough to decide that Marshall stays and Hartwell goes.    

by etabby on Sep 1, 2007 7:35 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

RE
I thought of that too. But I have to believe the team knew this before signing him. Perhaps this is a case that they had hoped he would flash once before he dimmed... and he never did.

by Kirkendall on Sep 1, 2007 8:10 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

No real surprises
Wright had some kind of foot injury. He was reportedly in a boot today. I think he would have made the squad -- and Keiwan would be looking for work -- if he hadn't gotten hurt.

Regarding Hartwell, Marvin said in his presser today that there was a possibility they could bring him back or another LB in next week. They are pretty thin there, with only 5 healthy guys.

Xzavie ought to make it to the PS. Ditto Everett. I hope Busing makes it through waivers.

The only thing that mildly surprised me was them keeping 3 TEs (not counting St. Louis).

by BeerRun on Sep 1, 2007 11:37 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Cincinnati Bengals.
Start posting about the Bengals »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Sixteenth ranked offense
Small
Something is different...
Small
Bengals in general
Infighting_small
Week 11 Preview: West Coast Warm Up
Infighting_small
Unabashed self-promotion in the name of humor
Small
Bengals Player Pick 'em Wk 11 vs Raiders
Cool_story_susan_small
Methinks they doth protest much too much
Small
The Raiders are the Really Hot Chick from Species
L_86ee73c18708491fbead6a796c68068f_small
DO YOU BELIEVE??? Who Dey
Jailbot_small
Bengals workout Joey Galloway on Tuesday

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Bleeding Green Nation
1:00 Games Open Thread
Pride Of Detroit
Lions-Browns Inactives
Bolts From The Blue
Game Thread: Early Games

Managers

Atari_small Kirkendall

Editors

Twitter_profile_pic_small A Pragmatic Bengals Fan

Authors

Small Vman in Germany

Oso-bengalslogo-animation_small Jay McDonnell

Raymualaga_small IFChris

Huber090426_440_small jsl413

Infighting_small Mojokong