Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Knicks 90, Raptors 87: "Shump and Lin wouldn't let us lose."

When all else fails, make really bad comparisons

Jerome Simpson on getting back to the field. "Being a competitor, I've still got that fire in me. It's not fun being injured. I've never had an injury before, so it's really a different experience for me. I'm trying to find the positive — just being smarter about the game and studying it more."

Simpson is being unfairly compared to DeSean Jackson as a means to prove that the Bengals scouting/drafting is wretched bad. If Simpson were drafted by the Eagles, his playing time would dramatically increase without having to leapfrog guys like Chad Johnson and T.J. Houshmandzadeh and, as el-insaciable points out, a majority of Jackson's playing time early in the season came on the heals of injured veteran receivers. Scouting/drafting does have super-flaws evident by the product, though this comparison doesn't fly. Six of the ten wide receivers drafted in the second round have yet to accumulate double-digit receptions, or triple-digit yards receiving. Guys like Eddie Royal and DeSean Jackson were introduced early as primary options thanks in part to unexpected injuries at their respective positions and guys like Donnie Avery and Jordy Nelson are on offenses that are successfully running a pass-first philosophy.

Player Drafted Team Games Rec Yards TDs
Donnie Avery 33 Rams 8 25 392 2
Devin Thomas 34 Redskins 9 8 63 0
Jordy Nelson 36 Packers 9 20 228 1
James Hardy 41 Bills 9 9 87 2
Eddie Royal 42 Broncos 8 52 625 4
Jerome Simpson 46 Bengals 4 1 2 0
DeSean Jackson 49 Eagles 9 38 586 1
Malcolm Kelly 51 Redskins 2 1 6 0
Limas Sweed 53 Steelers 4 4 39 0
Dexter Jackson 58 Buccaneers 7 0 0 0

Comment 2 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Yeah, in general, it’s really unfair to judge players by how they perform in their rookie year. It shouldn’t be expected (except for running backs) that a player become a major contributor right away. They have to learn the playbook first, and adjust to better teammates and opponents.

This year is just inviting those comparisons because of the incredible contributions some of the rookies are making on offense – QB (Ryan, Flacco) RB (Johnson, Forte) WR (Jackson, Royal, Avery), TE (Carlson), OL (several, but especially Ryan Clady). The defensive rookies are actually “struggling” a lot more than the offensive rookies, which is surprising.

by math_geek on Nov 12, 2008 1:24 PM EST reply actions  

Good point.

Blogger at CincyJungle.com -- SB Nation Cincinnati Bengals blog.

by Josh Kirkendall on Nov 12, 2008 1:29 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Cincinnati Bengals.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
What To Do With $60Million Dollars
Madmen_icon_small
Bengal Fans, Here's How to End Blackouts
Small
T-Cha's New Depth Mock Draft

Recent FanPosts

Small
Please go get Mario Williams Mike Brown!!!!!
Crucifixionbytheophanesthecretan_small
What positions do NFL teams really value? (Running Backs?)
33081-m_small
Curveball strategy
Small
Hello Again!
Picture_059_small
Filling holes in the roster: Guard
Thumbnail_small
Bengal4ever Mock / FA
Small
Is it possible to eliminate all the headaches while upgrading the roster?
Small
Is the best defense a good offense?
Small
If I could build the 2012 Bengals roster
Crucifixionbytheophanesthecretan_small
Calendar of a diehard Bengal’s fan

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Editor-In Chief

Cj_small Josh Kirkendall

5255_133614603784_666578784_2414703_1976100_n_small Jason Garrison

Editor/Managing Editor

Rudiblanket_small Anthony Cosenza

Authors

Photo_3_small BeerRun

010511170110_small Joe Goodberry

40297_422933299865_509514865_4658259_6466915_n_small Ryan Harper

Moderators

Nfl palewook

680764146_0eac16fabd_small 80%OFTHETIMEIMRIGHTEVERYTIME

Koolaid_small UpStateMike

Bengals_stamp_by_jamaal10_small Doc Scratch