What's your "core five"?
Chick Ludwig released his "fab five" -- five players that, in your opinion, are those that you must build around. Ludwig's are Carson Palmer, Chad Johnson, Robert Geathers, Leon Hall and Keith Rivers. Personally, I'm too fickle to create a list. Mine would change more than any history of stable Ohio weather. But I'm going to do this anyway. Don't let the fact bother you I might have 20 updates by lunch-time amending my list.
- Carson Palmer - No brainer.
- Stacy Andrews - I really believe the Bengals need to get this guy signed to a long-term deal. He's versatile, young and able while Willie Anderson is close to retirement and Levi Jones has entertained a trade demand.
- Robert Geathers - Even though his production slipped last season, Geathers can still have a monster career if he and Antwan Odom create match-up problems forcing tight ends and running backs to stay and block giving the defense an indirect advantage. There's a lot of expectations riding on the Geathers/Odom tandem this season.
- Four DBs - OK, I'm cheating here. And I'm actually making this #4 and #5. But Leon Hall, Johnathan Joseph, Chinedum Ndukwe and Marvin White combine for a youth movement with enough upside that gets me optimistically thinking that the Bengals could have one of the best secondaries by 2010.
There, my list. I know, awful. Who would you replace and why?
3 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I pretty much agree with your list. I love Ndukwe and believe he is going to turn into a stud. However I wish that somewhere on a list was a solid runningback. How sad do we look right now at that position. I love Rudi, but he is breaking down. Then Perry and Irons didn’t play at all. We won’t make another serious run until we get a healthy RB helping out our passing game.
Palmer for sure...
I also agree on Andrews. If he doesn’t sign a long term contract, franchising him will be a second recent front office blunder regarding the offensive line (the first being letting Steinbach go).
Leon Hall is a good choice—I have a feeling he may have a really good season. I agree with Geathers. I really want to say Keith Rivers, although he’s just rookie. If he turns in a solid season and has leadership qualities, he could make a huge difference.
Potential or not, I don’t think I’ll ever get franchising a backup(Andrews). I don’t even get franchising an only marginally productive starter(Justin Smith). Carson, for sure, maybe Whitworth/Collins as a cheating twofer anticipating an eventual Willie retirement and/or Levi trade, that four-headed monster in the defensive backfield, Ahmad Brooks if he gets his groin on straight, and I hate to say it but Chris Perry? I know it’s like betting on a picket fence to hold back flood waters.
I want to put Jason Shirley in there but I fear involuntary commitment.
by IgnatiusJReilly on May 26, 2008 11:19 AM EDT reply actions

by 
























