Cincy Jungle: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Post-UNC Thoughts

Carson Palmer != Tom Brady

Carsoninjury_medium

No, Tom Brady didn't have a hand in the Kimo von Oelhoffen hit that put Carson Palmer on the shelf, but the lack of fallout as opposed to Tom Brady's similar injury is where the aggravation comes in.  Thanks to a post from FanHouse, we now know about the NFL's adjustment of their "protect the quarterback rule, especially if he's Tom Brady" portion of the rulebook.

Termed the "Brady Rule," the change makes hits like Bernard Pollard's (and von Oelhoffen's) on Brady's knee a flagable offense.  Time for some blockquote text:

Brady tore his left ACL and left MCL in the first quarter of the Patriots' 17-10 win over the Chiefs Sept. 7. As Brady stepped into a 28-yard completion to Randy Moss, Chiefs safety Bernard Pollard made a desperation dive into Brady's left knee after he had been blocked to the ground just short of Brady by running back Sammy Morris.

Pollard was not flagged or fined for the hit. Under the revised rule, a play like his would be penalized, according to Titans coach Jeff Fisher and Falcons president Rich McKay, co-chairmen of the committee.

"I think all the quarterbacks in this league are critical to what the game is about," said Patriots owner Robert Kraft. "It's like if Peyton Manning were gone for a season, I think the whole NFL suffers, the same way the NFL suffered with Tommy out. So whatever we can do to protect quarterbacks and to minimize the opportunity of them being taken out with a year-ending injury I would support.

"It's not good for the league. What makes it special is special players. It's like going to see a great movie and the star isn't in the movie. It's the same principle."

Um, where was this outcry for quarterback knee protection -- as well as talk of protecting these athletic investments -- when Palmer was hit during the Pittsburgh game a few seasons ago? Where was move to change the rules in order to protect quarterbacks? Why did such a change only come after a Tom Brady is hurt, but not a Matt Schaub?

Proving once again that all players are not created equal, the NFL is all-of-a-sudden all about protecting the knees of NFL quarterback, who, at this rate, will be wearing flags on their hips in about two seasons -- of course, it takes an injury to the NFL's version of an NBA superstar before they neuter defensive players even more.

I'm left wondering what rule changes would've been made if it had been Damon Huard or Brodie Croyle suffering that injury instead of Brady?

0 recs  |  Comment 6 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Big deal if the player is penalized. So lets say you are a DE and you take out the knee of the other teams QB. You get a 15 yard penalty, but you have nearly sealed the win for your team because a scrub comes in to replace him. Will this mean that no one will tackle Tom Brady again. I hope not. I kind of enjoy it when there is a big hit on him. I was angry when it happened to Carson, but if KvO was penalized would the Bengals have still lost? There is nothing you can do that will protect the QB enough besides make them untouchable. That would be freaking boring. So unfortunately it is part of football, and the Bengals got the short end again.

Hines ward rule Again another rule that comes too late for the Bengals.

by ToledoRocket on Mar 24, 2009 4:40 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Penalty and an ejection

Might be a good deterrent, but I don’t think that’ll ever happen.

by IFChris on Mar 24, 2009 5:32 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Good take on the issue.

by Mike Boyd on Mar 24, 2009 6:51 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

i think people are missing the point here. the protection of a quarterback meaning all quarterbacks shouldnt matter who it is. people should just be glad that there is now a rule in play that will protect them. its not about thename or how iy came about

by hammer771970 on Mar 24, 2009 7:01 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

JP Losman

Same situation.

Zero publicity.

Think Rivers will happily take a 15 to take revenge on good ole Heinz.

by Squizza on Mar 24, 2009 9:03 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

The NFL Executives are making mistakes

Hello,

The executives of the NFL are making mistakes because they have chosen to allow the offense to run all over the defense. The NFL will never be the same until the defense is allowed to make contact with recievers and rough-up the quarterback in the pocket. The game should force the coaches to have some strategy heading into every game and not allow their quarterbacks to dropback and throw without any backfield protection.

This post is coming from a N.E. Patriot’s Fan

by Patriot Gnome on Mar 25, 2009 7:44 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Cincinnati Bengals.
Start posting about the Bengals »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Infighting_small
Week 11 Preview: West Coast Warm Up
Infighting_small
Unabashed self-promotion in the name of humor
Small
Bengals Player Pick 'em Wk 11 vs Raiders
Cool_story_susan_small
Methinks they doth protest much too much
Small
The Raiders are the Really Hot Chick from Species
L_86ee73c18708491fbead6a796c68068f_small
DO YOU BELIEVE??? Who Dey
Jailbot_small
Bengals workout Joey Galloway on Tuesday
Small
Give LJ a Break
Infighting_small
Week 10 Recap: Meet The New Boss
Rookie_minicamp09-17--nfl_medium_540_360_small
LJ has his eyes sought on KC Week 16

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Cincy Jungle
Are the Bengals Super Bowl Contenders?
Mobile Live
St. Louis Rams fantasy report, week 11, Rams vs. Arizona
Field Gulls
Replacing Colin Cole

Managers

Atari_small Kirkendall

Editors

Twitter_profile_pic_small A Pragmatic Bengals Fan

Authors

Bengals_elvis_small Mike Boyd

Small Vman in Germany

Oso-bengalslogo-animation_small Jay McDonnell

Raymualaga_small IFChris

Huber090426_440_small jsl413