Andrew Whitworth is the Cincinnati Bengals starting left tackle
![]() |
| This fuzzy screen-cap is Andrew Whitworth's departure after defending himself from the eye-gorging defensive tackle, John Henderson. |
Is it a surprise that the Cincinnati Bengals moved Andrew Whitworth to left tackle and Andre Smith at right tackle during their first day of OTA? We battled the idea amongst ourselves, the mighty warriors of conjecture, prophesy and forecasting. How will Bengals offensive line will stack up, we asked. Apparently, the offensive tackles are already set.
(Marvin Lewis) said after practice that's how the tackles are going to line up as long as he's the head coach.
"When I watched (Smith) on tape, that's what he looked like to me. It looked like he would have an opportunity to be real successful," Lewis said. "I feel real good about Andrew and what he can do on the other side. I feel like that kind of locks us down for a lot of years for two very key spots ... as long as I'm here.
"It fits the pieces the right way. Nate did a lot of good things at the end of last year getting an opportunity to play for the first time when we played real football. But we've got some other guys competing there with (Andrew) Crummey and (Evan) Mathis. We have to see what we've got."
The newlywed is pumped, apparently thinking that marriage isn't challenging enough.
"Now that I've got a chance to be the left tackle, I want to devote myself to being the guy they can rely on as their franchise guy; that's where I want myself," Whitworth said. "You're playing on an island and there's a different tempo to things you do at tackle and guard. There'll be a change in tempo, a little bit of a transition getting used to that."
We applaud the decision. We applaud it because it was made now. In May. No OTA musical chairs. No training camp competition. No preseason mix-and-matching. None of that. The Bengals have a left tackle now, and his name is Andrew Whitworth.
Now all that aside, with Smith being the team's right tackle, what of Anthony Collins; the guy that impressed us so much last year stepping up to the plate against some of the league's best pass rushers? Apparently, he's going to be the team's first backup tackle. That's right. Our offensive line is filled with so much depth that our backup tackle is a guy that shutdown the NFL's 2008 Defensive Player of the Year on a national Thursday Night broadcast who is now pouting because he thinks the only winners visit the White House. Well, national is relative because it was on the NFL Network. But still. Impressive none-the-less. Not a bad thing we have going with our offensive tackles.
7 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
This move say, ‘We want to win right now’
Smith may have the talent to be a great LT. He certainly shut down NFL talent in the SEC, but Marvin doesn’t want to risk Carsons back with on the job training. Whit may be best suited for RT, with his size and limited mobility, but he’s never played on the right side, so it would be some adjustment for him also.
Time will tell if this is a smart move, but I think Marvin knows his leashe is getting shorter and that he needs to get it down now. But I like the decisiveness. None of this messing around with the Jurassic 5, and limiting the snaps of the guys who will actually be out there.
Also, its interesting that Nate Livings gets the nod over Collins.
I have no qualms whatsoever with Andre Smith at RT. That’s where I thought he belonged from the get-go but moving Whit from the LG spot- where I think he naturally fits, and leaving Collins on the bench is not putting your best players on the field at the same time. Nothing against Livings, Nate did a great job last year when called on. It just makes no sense to go from a projected left side of Whit and Collins to Livings and Whit. When, exactly, has Whit demonstrated that he could handle the elite speed rushers of the NFL?
by IgnatiusJReilly on May 19, 2009 9:04 PM EDT reply actions
all good points
We could have put whit at LT Collins at RT and Livings at LG and drafted Brian Orakpo or Knowshon Moreno.
But here is a different thought. We all know how confident Collins is. He’s boarderline Cocky. so maybe he felt like he was going to be handed the starting LT job. That all he had to do was show up and be the guy. Maybe he showed up out of shape, and Marvin took a stand. We really dont know what happened behind the scenes. Maybre " hard knocks" will give us some insight? that would be fun.
by Joe Goodberry on May 20, 2009 12:21 AM EDT up reply actions
I never really trust what Marvin says to the media
Remember when he said things would be “blown up” last off season only to see no significant changes made. And leading up to each of the previous two seasons he has proclaimed we would employ a power rushing attack only to see it abandoned by the regular season.
I’m just saying the more I think about this the more I take it with a grain of salt. I’ve always liked Whitworth as a tackle but think hes more of a RT in the NFL.
With the current roster I like Collins as the starting LT and Whitworth sliding over to LT only incase of injurty and RT incase of long holdout
Whit has shown that he is consistant, He brings his best every game without outside drama. Collins is doing great and he’ll get his chance. I’m glad these changes are happening. We always seem to expect something different from the same players and never get it, Now at the very least we can look to different things from this team.
I don't like it
I am a HUGE Whitworth fan. He plays hard and with intensity and has a mean streak when he needs to. I just liked him so much at guard last year. He was taking on Henderson and Haynseworth and was giving them fits. I don’t deny that Whit has the talent to be a good LT, but I think he has a much better shot at being a Pro Bowl Guard.
It's still a good season if we go 2-14 and beat the Steelers twice.
I like it
One thing the move brings is depth at Tacklle. Anthony Collins provides great depth as the back-up for both Tackle positions. Livings played well at guard, and will bring some (if limited) starting experience next to Cook until Luigs is ready.

by 




















