Bad Owner, Bad Drafts and Bad Luck....A look at the Bengals' history.
The Cincinnati Bengals are not your typical NFL franchise. Paul Brown was the owner, general manager and head coach when they began play in the AFL in 1967. It seems like a recipe for disaster having one man for all three positions, but Paul Brown was a football genius. When he retired following the 1975 season the Bengal franchise was never the same. I wanted to write an article about some serious reasons why the Cincinnati Bengals franchise have struggled over the years.
(1) Greg Cook gets hurt - The Bengals drafted QB Greg Cook with their 1st round pick in 1969. Having played at the University of Cincinnati, Cook was an instant fan favorite. The 1969 team came roaring out of the gates winning their first 3 games. However, Cook sustained a shoulder injury in game 3 against the Chiefs, but finished out the season with a bumb shoulder. The team would win just one more game that year, but Cook was named Rookie of the Year. It was later discovered that Greg Cook had torn his rotator cuff in game 3. His playing career was essentially over before it began.
(2) Mike Reid chooses the piano - With their number 1 pick in 1970, the Bengals selected Penn State's defensive lineman Mike Reid. Reid played only 5 seasons, but was named NFL All-Pro in 4 of those seasons. With such a strong start to his career, it was a shock when he retired from football after the 1974 season to pursue a musical career. Reid went on to be a concert pianist and later had a successful country music career. He even won a Grammy.
(3) Brown chooses the wrong Bill - Following the 1975 season, Paul Brown retired as head coach and named Bill "Tiger" Johnson as his replacement. Ironically, he passed over a Bengals assistant coach named Bill Walsh, who coached his 49ers to 2 Super Bowl wins over the Bengals in the 1980s.
(4) Tommy Casanova says the "eyes" have it - LSU defensive back Tommy Casanova was the Bengals round 2 pick in 1972. Tommy was a 4 time Pro Bowl selection during his brief 6 year career. While playing football, he began pursuing a medical degree. Casanova retired after the 1977 season to become a full-time medical student. He later became an opthalmalogist and still practices today.
(5) Mike Brown takes over after the death of Paul Brown - 101-188, That's the Bengals record since Mike took over. I don't need to describe the horrible Bengal existance since 1991.
The Mike Brown era is where I'll stop numbering specific events that changed the Cincinnati Bengals' history because Mike and daughter Katie have ruined an NFL franchise. I will name some examples of typical Bengal luck. In no particular order, I'll just write my memories as they come to mind.
other Bad Bengal memories or events
Stanley Wilson goes on a cocaine binge the night preceding SB XXIII - CB Lewis Billups drops a game clinching interception in SB XXIII - let Boomer Esiason go - ruined a great defensive coordinator's (Dick LeBeau) reputation by making him head coach and treating him like a puppet - six (0-6) starts and 4 (0-8) starts since 1991 - drafted a run & shoot QB David Klingler and try to make him into a conventional style QB - brought in Reggie Rembert from the Jets - Number 1 overall pick Big Daddy Wilkinson turned out mediocre - Number 1 overall pick Kijana Carter blows out his knee in his first game - drafted Akili Smith number 3 overall pick -No 1 pick David Pollack sustains a career ending neck injury - 2nd round pick Kenny Irons never plays a down because of a knee injury - No 1 pick Chris Perry never developes following a nagging sports hernia - ect, ect, ect until Mike Brown dies and someone kidnaps Katie.
Oh, I forgot all the wonderfull off the field arrests and problems....Who Dey!
This is a FanPost and does not necessarily reflect the views of Cincy Jungle's writers or editors. It does reflect the views of this particular fan though, which is as important as the views of Cincy Jungle's writers or editors.
17 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
BOY!!!! THAT SAYS IT ALL.
Reading this on the day that the Bengals win. But it’s true. We can dance, party, and chant WHO-DEY all week long and it won’t change the story. The story will stay the same. Though, I will always be a Bengals fan, or at least until MB pulls a ART MODILF, like up in BROWN-HOLE COUNTRY. But for now WHOOOOOOO-DEYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!! Bring them SUCK-BUTT STEaLERS ON!!!!!
Don't forget Odell Thurmond and David Pollack
some bad luck there on both accounts.
"Ryan, Things in here don't react too well to bullets." - Marko Ramius
Didn't evem get into
Ickey Williams career being cut short, Big Daddy Wilkinson, Akili Smith, David Klingler, Chris Perry, Ki-Jana Carter.
It's still a good season if we go 2-14 and beat the Steelers twice.
lol woops
Don’t know what I was thinking on that one
It's still a good season if we go 2-14 and beat the Steelers twice.
by Bengals FTW on Sep 22, 2009 10:33 AM EDT up reply actions
out of all the miscues
the one that changed us or set us down this current path the most was not choosing Bill Walsh. He could have put the franchise on the cutting edge of the NFL evolution before Paul Brown’s slow son Mikey took complete control of the steering wheel.
Wyche was pretty damn good.
Wyche ended up 61-66 as the Bengals head coach. Mike Brown took over in 1991, quickly turning a winning team into a 3-13 juggernaut. Sam was 58-53 before Paul Brown died. Sam was fired Christmas eve following that 1991 season.
"A lie can travel around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes".....Mark Twain
you have a point
but Bill Walsh taught Sam Wyche everything he knew-first as a Bengal Off coordinator/qb coach when Whyche was a Bengals QB then as Wyche was QB coach for Walshs’ 49ers.
Hiring Wyche was almost a make up to passing over Walsh.
i should weigh in with the first thing that came to mind though...
while its fun to think about what could have been with Walsh, the Bengals had literally ZERO chance to keep him here.
think back to Tom Callahan’s book The Bases Were Loaded and So Was I. the book goes into the topic of Walsh and it was a lost cause for a few reasons. for one, Paul Brown simply promised the job to Tiger years before, so Walsh would have had to be on staff at a lower position—something Walsh was not about to do. so the bengals threw money at Walhs to keep him on their staff, but his ultimate goal was to live on the west coast. so he took a position with the Chargers and the rest is history.
it’s nice to think we could have had Walsh thus changing the landscape of football forever, but it was extremely unlikely given the promise of the job to Johnson and the West Coast thing.
do you mean
Walsh would have turned down the head coaching job if it had been offered? Or that he would have left eventualy.
Walsh had a falling out....
Bill and Paul Brown split on bad terms. I’m not certain why, but promising the job to Tiger Johnson probably had something to do with it. I watched a bio on Walsh just after he died and the bio stated that PBrown tried to blackball Walsh from the NFL. Oh, wouldn’t Boomer have really thrived with Walsh?
"A lie can travel around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes".....Mark Twain
Paul didn't give Walsh
the job eventhough it would have been the right move. Bengal legacy-do it my way or the highway. Choosing Walsh would have meant putting a creative cutting edge offensive minded coach at the helm-much like Paul had been in his younger days in coaching. Maybe Paul didn’t want the compitition or maybe he was growing too conservative in his old age or maybe he was just a man of his word who kept a promise.
He made a promise....
and PB was going to honor it. Whether we like the Brown Family or not, they are faithful to the people they make a contract with. Mike will always be known as the “Rat Bastard that owns the Bengals”, but truth be know, he’s probably a warm, caring person.
Most people would call him a good business man, but he doesn’t know football like PB, so trying to run the team like Daddy will not work. ……Half correct:
A good business man involved in a factory type business would be smart enough to realize when his business needs a plant manger. Mike won’t hire a GM, we all know that. The point I want to make is: YES , Mike Brown thinks he can run the Bengals just like his Daddy, but NO, MB is a good business man. Because a good one hires a GM!
"A lie can travel around the world while the truth is putting on its shoes".....Mark Twain





















