Question of the Day (or Season So Far): Is it Okay to Boo Your Home Team?
I don't think I've been to a Bengals game this season in which the fans didn't boo at one point. Even in their only home win, against the Baltimore Ravens -- a division rival -- the fans booed the Bengals at times. There have been games that the Bengals lost this year in which there seemed to be more booing than cheering. When it was announced over the PA system at the stadium during the game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers that Carson Palmer had surpassed 20,000 career passing yards, there were boos and cheers, but the boos quickly drowned out the cheers. At least that's how it was in my section.
One wonders how the players feel about being booed in their own stadium by their own fans. Do they completely ignore it or does it bother them in some way that they just don't talk about?
Well sometimes, players do talk about it. In a radio interview, New York Giants safety Antrel Rolle spoke about the fact that the Giants fans were booing their own team as they left the field in their last game against the Jacksonville Jaguars.
"I don’t like it one bit," Rolle said. "We’re not going to always have those dominant, blowout games. We’re not going to win each and every game although we would love to. But through it all, our fans are huge. They play a critical part in our game whether they know it or not. No they’re not on the field, no they’re not making the plays, no they’re not playing. But at the same time we need them to have confidence as we have confidence in ourselves. The booing, honestly, it pissed me off. That’s something that I haven’t heard since I’ve been here.
"You don’t boo your team," Rolle continued. "I don’t care what happens, you don’t boo your team. That’s my take on it. You don’t boo your team. This is your home team. We’re out there playing, we’re out there pouring our heart out for our fans, you don’t boo your team. I don’t care what the situation is, you don’t boo your team. We’re 7-4. We’re not 2-10, we’re 7-4. There are going to be ups and downs during the season. (Not) under any circumstances should you boo your team. That’s just the reality of it."
Buying a single game ticket or season tickets is like signing a contract. The buyer will pay a certain amount of money in exchange for the seller to place the best possible product on the field. Obviously there is no NFL ticket refund policy so if the seller doesn't follow through with their side of the bargain, what is the fan to do?
The question of is it right for a fan to boo his or her own team comes down to the concept of ownership. I know that I do not own the Cincinnati Bengals (kind of wish I did). However, I also know that without the paying fans in Cincinnati, a team would not be able to exist. I am a paying fan. So, since a team wouldn't have the ability to exist with out us (the fans), it is possible to think, in a roundabout way, that a fan owns a small piece of the team. Does that give a fan the right to boo?
Even though booing is obviously worse than cheering it still isn't as bad as it can get. In fact, it can get much worse. When I was young and would get in trouble, my parents would punish me. After it was all done, they usually took the time to let me know that it would be much easier for them to not care what I do but they punish me because the love me. Of course, it didn't make sense that somebody who loved me would take away my Playstation at the time, but I get it now.
Booing is one thing, but the Bengals will really know they're in trouble when fans just stop caring. When Carson Palmer throws an interception and he hears crickets chirping instead of booing, he'll know that he's hit rock bottom. Maybe, the fans that boo are the fans that love their team the most.
In that case, players shouldn't get bent out of shape when they hear it. At least there is somebody who cares. Sometimes, the Bengals don't even deserve that.
Do you think it's okay for fans to boo their own teams?
23 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
If ticket prices we're based on performance and fluctuated accordingly I might say don't boo.
But because the team and the league do nothing to soften the blow of a terrible team I think you pay a premium price to be ticked off if you want.
by JamesShively on Nov 30, 2010 5:59 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
Fans don't boo because of the person playing the game
Fans boo for the play on the field. If you team sucks and you (as I do most of the time) feel that they don’t care that they’re losing (see Derek Anderson MNF) then boo the crap out of them. A fan can boo for poor play on the field or poor results. Not to say that you can boo relentlessly even if things are going well, but you have to right do to whatever you want.
by TheCinWin on Nov 30, 2010 6:31 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
People pay good money to go watch football games.
I’m not really one for actually booing the team, but I don’t give a shit if people do decide to boo. I voted for “Who Cares?,” but not in the dicky way.
"I bet that sex Bengals fan is really pissed now." -DT3428
Same here, although I bet this story will rile up some fans:
http://news.cincinnati.com/article/20101130/COL03/311300097/T-shirt-gets-Bengals-fan-in-trouble
IMO, truth lies somewhere in between. He probably was being obnoxious, and complaints probably had been filed by people who just wanted to watch the game. They were already agitated by the play on the field, didn’t need some dummy standing up and waving his shirt around and blocking his view.
Just wear the shirt buddy. In all likelihood was not kicked out for the message on the shirt, although that’s what P-Doc wants you to think.
How will Chris Carpenter explain this to his children?
I know it has been said before but just don't give Mike Brown money
It is clear that if you are coming to this site, you are a pretty hardcore Bengals fan. I wouldn’t think of rooting for another team but I also don’t “support” the team financially. I have never been to a game, never bought any Bengals merchandise, and never will as long as Mike Brown is dragging the organization through what he has. That is not to say that I haven’t thought about buying something (practically every season), but I know nothing will change if Mike Brown still is getting paid. If I felt like the Bengals were producing a product that was worthy, there is no doubt in my mind that I would support it financially.
Back to the original point of this post, I don’t think fans should boo, I think fans just shouldn’t go to games. Booing does nothing, as we have seen for the past 20 years. The fans are not really booing the players as much as the situation, and that falls firmly on the shoulders of ownership. The players come and go. The only way there will be change is if there is an uprising of fans that refuse to continue giving Mike Brown money. Although I love watching the Bengals on Sundays, I think these blackouts are good and hope they continue for the rest of the season (and into next season, or until whenever it finally dawns on MB).
get over it guys...(attention player)
1)To mike Brown, a fan that boos is better than one who stays home.
2) should Bengals fan cheer…better question
3) if it pisses you off and you win…what’s the problem? Did it work?
4) blow me… prove me wrong.
by quickslant on Nov 30, 2010 7:48 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Do whatever the heck you want. You have the "right" to do whatever you want.
But I have zero respect for somebody who boos their team. It’s tacky, rude, and more. If you really hate their playing that much, just don’t go to the game. Or leave. But don’t stand there and heckle the team. Especially when half the problem (or more) really isn’t the players on the field.
Worse yet nobody knows what you are booing for. Are you booing the playcalling? Are you booing the execution? Are you booing the QB or the RB or the OL or the WR? Or maybe it’s the defense, are you booing the DL who can’t get the QB, or the CB who slipped and fell down giving up a big play? You just don’t know.
I’m all for expressing intelligent, rational disgust for the direction of team, online or offline. I’m all for putting up billboards dissing Mike or calling for a GM or whatever. I’m all for expressing your anger at the way the season has gone. But do it in a rational, dignified fashion. Don’t just throw boos.
by FriarBob on Nov 30, 2010 7:49 PM EST reply actions 1 recs
"when half the problem (or more) really isn’t the players on the field"
Really, is Mike Brown throwing interceptions, or dropping passes or missing tackles? What is being booed is what is on the field. People don’t come to games to boo but when they see bad things on the field they react, you know kind of like when you see something good happen on the field you cheer.
Well Antrel, were 2-9, is that close enough?
Very few NFL teams know what it is like to be in our shoes. Most franchises can’t stand more that a couple of years of losing and their fans go nuts. We have seen it, and put up with it for decades… I haven’t been to a winning sporting event in Cincinnati in 20 years, every game that I have been to (baseball, football, or hockey), we have lost.
MIKE BROWN STEP DOWN!!!
our hockey team is incredible..
just sayin.
by 80%OFTHETIMEIMRIGHTEVERYTIME on Dec 1, 2010 10:30 AM EST up reply actions
It has been a while since I have been to a hockey game...
Actually the last game I went to was the Ducks and they were down like 3 or 4 with 7 minutes left, so I left, when I got home the news was on and they had come back and won. So I guess that was a win. Maybe I’m just bad luck…
MIKE BROWN STEP DOWN!!!
Your mistake...
Your mistake was going to a Ducks game, hit a Cyclones game lots more fun.
Football is entertainment..
and represents the city.
So Bengals fail on both accounts, I will boo until the day they fix this BS, POS team!
by 80%OFTHETIMEIMRIGHTEVERYTIME on Dec 1, 2010 10:29 AM EST reply actions
sad, sad, sad
Should we BOO the Bengals? You bet your ass we should! What are our other options? Cheer? For what? Give me a team to cheer for and I’m all about it. If we could field a winning team, that stadium whould be so loud even Mike Brown would hear it. Lord knows he isn’t hearing anything else we’ve said…
"We will reach heights we thought we'd never see"

by 























