Grading the offseason for the Bengals means comparing them to the AFC North
Marvin Lewis joined Antonio Bryant during a press conference on Friday, introducing the receiver to the Cincinnati media. While most believe that Bryant will be a big improvement over the ineffective Laveranues Coles, Marvin Lewis was asked about the offseason so far.
"Well, we’ve signed a receiver and I feel really good about that," Lewis said. "I feel good about the direction we took this season and so far with our organization. I think we got some of our needs prior to the draft being filled with veteran players, which enables us when we come to the draft to be completely open. To look at the best prospect and then draft based on that which is a good situation."
Some would argue that aside from the Bryant signing, the Bengals haven't improved during free agency. Chris Davis being the only other player that wasn't on the roster last season, the Bengals signed an additional three players, Tank Johnson, Roy Williams and Daniel Coats -- all of whom were on the squad last year. Alternatively, they've only lost two players to other teams -- Shaun Smith was very limited in his contributions and Larry Johnson was only a thought when Cedric Benson and Bernard Scott battled injury. Admittedly, neither player is a loss and two restricted free agents weren't tendered, J.P. Foschi and Matt Sherry, making them unrestricted free agents.
And as of this posting two starters that are still free agents, Bobbie Williams and Reggie Kelly, will likely return. But they're still not signed. And that always draws concerns with a negotiation group led by Katie Blackburn -- her negotiation segments on Hard Knocks with Andre Smith still give me horrifying nightmares.
So the Bengals have been boring. They're not making moves to satisify an impatient fanbase that wants the team to at least make their best effort on every player that's available. We're not people who like watching other teams sign quality players while we're perceived as sitting on our hands. Boring. One has to be reminded that this team won the AFC North, won ten games and swept the division, which included two teams that played in the AFC Championship game in 2008. That team is coming back in 2010. Will it be enough? One could argue if you sit status quo in the NFL, you're going to fall behind too quickly to react.
HAS ANYONE IN THE DIVISION REALLY DOMINATED THE OFFSEASON? When you sit back and analyze the Bengals' offseason thus far, you have crossover with other teams and see what they're up to. How are others within the division faring? Are you concerned about the Steelers, Ravens or Browns? Has any team improved that much to confidently say that they are the clear division favorites?
The Baltimore Ravens signed troubled receiver Donte Stallworth, traded for Anquan Boldin and brought Derrick Mason back on a two-year deal. They did sign Jim Zorn as the team's quarterback coach, but who knows how that will improve quarterback Joe Flacco. Have the Ravens made the moves up to this point to be the better team in the division?
"Boldin brings credibility to the Ravens passing attack, which has been without that big name #1 wideout for years," said Bruce Raffel of the Ravens blog Baltimore Beatdown. "Now combining Boldin with Derrick Mason, gives us a passing attack that will complement our running game enough to put enough points on the board to support their solid defense and go deep into the post season once again, and this time to the Big Game."
The Steelers signed Casey Hampton to a long-term deal, re-signed Ryan Clark, tagged place kicker Jeff Reed, brought Antwaan Randle El and Larry Foote back and signed receiver Arnaz Battle. Have the Steelers improved, or are they status quo, keeping their own and signing role players in free agency?
The Browns have made some moves, mostly related to clearing out their roster for draft picks. They signed a few veterans like Tony Pashos and Jake Delhomme. They signed linebacker Scott Fujita and then traded Kamerion Wimbley. We call that a draw. On the other hand, they cut Steve Heiden and replaced him with semi-effective Benjamin Watson at tight end. Of all the teams in the AFC North, the Browns could make the most noise when the NFL Draft wraps up. Still, this doesn't mean the Browns will make bold strides toward competing for the division this season. There's too much personnel turnover and too much youth that's about to be embedded into the roster to think Cleveland's chances of winning the AFC North to be realistic at this point. But at least they're doing it right this time, building a roster from the ground up.
On paper using the age old method of scanning for names and comparing what you know of those players in your mind, none of the AFC North teams clearly dominated free agency. The Browns are looking to use 12 draft picks during April's NFL Draft to improve their squad. The Bengals, Ravens and Steelers, all of whom are relatively content with their roster, are filling gaps to improve recent successes.
It would be one thing to claim that the Bengals aren't improving whereas the other division teams are. But like the Bengals, the Steelers and Ravens are keeping their core players, adding maybe one big-named player while looking to draft players to build their respective foundation. No one in the AFC North signed Julius Peppers, Karlos Dansby, Aaron Kampman, Dunta Robinson, Gary Brackett, LaDainian Tomlinson, Thomas Jones or Chester Taylor. In fact, of all the free agents, the Bengals may have added the best receiver available in Antonio Bryant within the division. The best any team has done that's comparable was the Ravens trading for Anquan Boldin.
WHAT'S ON TAP? While Cincinnati hasn't made the moves that makes us dance in the streets, singing backup vocals to the naked cowboy, the Bengals are standing firm with a roster composed of players that won last year. They are standing firm with the players that got them to the playoffs in 2009. But they're also aware that a majority of those players aren't just talented, they're leaders and everyone on the squad is big-picture minded. Yes, even Chad Ochocinco is thinking this way now.
Restricted free agents like Brandon Johnson, Abdul Hodge, Frostee Rucker and Evan Mathis are still unsigned, while Rashad Jeanty is being courted by the Miami Dolphins. Once those players are signed, and once the Bengals get Bobbie Williams and Reggie Kelly back, Cincinnati will focus on building their squad through the NFL draft.
And the NFL Draft is exactly what each AFC North team is looking to make their biggest moves during the offseason.
0 recs |
40 comments
|
Comments
Boldin is by far the best addition any AFC North team has made.
Besides Jake Delhomme signing with the Browns,.. the Ravens getting Boldin should pay huge dividends for them right away. Boldin was considered a top ten wideout in the league the last few years, while Bryant has had one really good season over the course of his entire career. But, overall none of our rivals have upgraded themselves beyond reproach.
Since we re-signed Daniel Coats, I consider this the worst offseason in team history. What I mean is, when a player almost costs you two or three wins by his inept receiving skills/ butter fingers how do you justify rewarding him? Why didn’t they resign Brad St. Louis too?
Our kicking situation really scares the hell out of me. Graham was very consistent most of the time and now we’re left with a 70% lifetime kicker who was cut by the Chiefs two years ago and hasn’t kicked for a team on a regular basis since! Surely we’ll sign a solid veteran kicker before training camp right?
"You shouldn't throw rocks at a man with a machine gun." - Rowdy Roddy Piper
by St. Esiason on Mar 21, 2010 12:05 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
When was the last time Boldin played an entire season without some nagging injury?
Additionally, how many #2 guys in the NFL successfully transition to a team’s #1 WR?
I’m confident that Leon and JJ will shut him down like they’ve done everyone else sans Andre Johnson. We’ll pick up a quality nickle in the draft and after that Boldin doesn’t scare me.
by Craig Conrad on Mar 22, 2010 8:01 AM EDT up reply actions
FYI
Bolden played #1 his rookie year and I believe the first and second year of Fitzgerald’s career. He can make the transition just fine, but the injuries are definitely an issue.
With the 18th pick of the 2010 NFL Draft the Pittsburgh Steelers select Florida QB Tim Tebow. (not a RB!)
I think It won't matter if he plays less than 16 games
Because if he can have a 10+ TD and 1,000+ receiving yard season, So be it!
Please register for this great American football RPG through this link:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/signup.pl?ref=34554501
by Baltimore Warrior on Mar 22, 2010 3:46 PM EDT up reply actions
Yeah but if you lose him for the playoffs
Then you are the same team you were last year…
With the 18th pick of the 2010 NFL Draft the Pittsburgh Steelers select Florida QB Tim Tebow. (not a RB!)
True
But recently they haven’t been too serious. usually it’s just been1-3 weeks
Please register for this great American football RPG through this link:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/signup.pl?ref=34554501
by Baltimore Warrior on Mar 22, 2010 4:30 PM EDT up reply actions
Not sure about your point
Football is a physical, violent sport. Boldin is a guy that does not shy away from contact. Lets use Bengal WR’s as an example to illustrate my point. Ochocinco can run dig, crossing, and slants routes. He will even catch some of these balls in traffic but I would say it is not a strength or something he has great interest in (to be kind). Ditto Caldwell and Coles and thus the Bengals experience passing problems minus TJ.
I disagree with your premise that Boldin is not a #1 guy. 1B would have been more accurate. The stats support this. Boldin had been that guy prior to Fitz in AZ (see rookie season). In the Arizona scheme Boldin almost exclusively ran dig, crossing and slant routes while Fitzgerald ran the post, corner and go routes away from traffic and contact. It takes a special player both physically and mentally to run those routes on the tree knowing the safety or LB is coming everytime. With Mason back in tow, Boldin does not nor will he be asked to run inside routes exclusively thereby preserving his health and taking “less” shots.
All NFL players (that play significant snaps) experience injuries during the course of a long and grueling NFL.
Jake Delhomme?
I can’t believe he is going to be that amazing in 2010, unless you want to talk about # of interceptions thrown.
I bet he has a clause in his contract that pays him more money if he has less than 20 INTs
For every 1 less INT thrown he gets 100k
Please register for this great American football RPG through this link:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/signup.pl?ref=34554501
by Baltimore Warrior on Mar 22, 2010 3:47 PM EDT up reply actions
I think we've gotten better.
It’s hard to understate how important the WR situation was. Given, Bryant is still somewhat of an unknown commodity, lets say for arguments sake he is the upgrade over Coles that we think he is. Assuming that, we’ve filled what I think was our single biggest deficiency last year.
The Ravens have gotten better too. As of now, I think it’s a toss-up between our two teams for the AFCN. Their D may not be what it once was, but w/ Boldin and Rice, their offense could be downright scary next year.
The Steelers are hard to pin-down, underperforming last year and their QB situation a huge unknown at this time. We were better than them last year though, so unless they make some real improvements I find it hard to think that we won’t continue to be.
The Browns – who knows? They’re a clusterf***, but when you’ve got a squad full of guys potentially playing for their jobs headed by one of the smartest guys working in the league…they could do something. It’ll certainly be another rebuilding year for them, but I wouldn’t write them off.
All things considered, I believe the AFC North will continue to be one of the best divisions in the NFL.
Thanks guys
for putting my thoughts in this piece and I agree with you, that it is looking for a wild season in the AFC North, with pretty much every team upgrading in some way. With the Steelers, sometimes keeping the team intact is the best thing to do, and with the Big Ben issues, they might be distracted enough to battle it out with the Browns for the cellar, which would be fine w/ both of us, eh? Peace.
aka 'Rexx'
by Bruce Raffel on Mar 21, 2010 12:25 PM EDT up reply actions
We'll get better just from the draft
It’s nice to be in a situation where our picks aren’t needed to fill holes all over the field. How often have the Bengals been drafting for depth rather than immediate starters? The payoff will be later in the season, when inevitable injuries ding up some people, and these role players get in there. And as for our one major addition – Bryant – as long as people are forced to respect him even a little bit early, he will payoff for us. I think it’s safe to say by the end of the year, no team was worried about covering anyone but Chad and playing the run.
Now, as for the competition, the Steelers D is not what it once was, and they need all sorts of secondary help (imo). I don’t think they’ll fix it either, even with the draft. And their offense has been decent, but no longer run first, and while Ben is ok, I’d rather he be forcing things than them being a team that runs over people. Our D can handle that now.
The Browns? Who here is not happy that Delhomme is at the helm? His last 2 years have been a joke. And he had Steve Smith to throw to, and a two-headed monster at RB. Who does he have in Cleveland? Anyone? They’ll be a big question mark, but I think it’ll be a comedy of errors there this coming year.
As for the Ravens, their offense was scary last year. Boldin makes things a bit more challenging. But I still think our defense matches up better with them than their D does with us, because they have the same problem as the Steelers – their D is old. They have needs at every level, and their corners are even worse than the Steelers. They’ll be like the Bengals of 05-06 – they’ll have to outscore people to win. And with a top 5 D on our side, I’m not too worried about that.
by rorschach1979 on Mar 21, 2010 12:51 PM EDT up reply actions
Except All three teams had top 5 D's last year.
So age isn’t killing anyone yet. As much as I hate the Steelers, they will always have a good defense with Dick being the mastermind. The Ravens don’t have that brilliant DC, but somehow we’ve been a top 6 D for the past half decade while people predict it’s decline due to age. We all face a tougher schedule but I still would not be surprised if we were all in the top 10 D’s again this year.
Browns- regrouping
Ravens- Ray Ray and Reed due for wheelchair and Boldin doesn’t have Fitz to hide behind.
Steelers- Ben, what are you thinking? Time to bust out Dixon.
Bengals- AB will be solid and who dey all the way to being repeat AFCN champs! Zimm will have another great and better D
by quickslant on Mar 21, 2010 1:14 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
I'm also ok
with you winning the AFCN again this year if it means we consistently make it past you in the playoffs.
by ATXRaven on Mar 22, 2010 8:12 AM EDT up reply actions 2 recs
+1
Please register for this great American football RPG through this link:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/signup.pl?ref=34554501
by Baltimore Warrior on Mar 22, 2010 3:47 PM EDT up reply actions
while we need to see what comes out of the draft
Baltimore should be a big-time threat this year. Their lack of anyone for Flacco to throw to was their problem in ’09, and they went out and did what it took to change it. I fully expect to see them with a good young CB coming out of the first round as well…
This is the best division in football right now.
The Ravens should run away with it though. Boldin is a game changer, but the Ravens O was going to grow anyway. Flacco is going to be a 3rd year pro. the O line and Ray Rice are very young and improving. Last year it was 26ppg, 8th in ypg, this year it should be top 3.
The D is not nearly as old or declining as I am sure Bengal fans would hope. The Steelers D fell apart down the stretch without Troy P., but the Ravens D was getting better since the bye week, despite losing 2 of the top 3 CBs, Suggs, Reed and Nagta for stretches. Ray is getting up there, Gregg, Pryce, Reed, but look at the rest of the roster, Nagta, Suggs, Johnson, Landry and most of the starters will be around for a long time.
I was shocked to see the Bengal O line and Benson break the 100 yard streak, and I think it will cause Oz to beef up the D line.
The Browns won the last 4 games and knocked the Stelers out of the playoffs, the Steelers only fell off because Troy got hurt and the Bengals looked great until they locked up the division. If I was a Bengal fan, I would be a little concenred about Palmer. Flacco had better passing numbers and now has a lot more playoff wins. The WRs were not that bad and the run game should have opened up the deep ball, but I did not see the old Carson Palmer arm. The protection was pretty good, he showed more than I though he has in scrambling for 1st downs, but he may have a rag arm and questionable heart.
by Harm City Homer on Mar 21, 2010 1:46 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
I have to be honest
It’s hard for me to be impressed by a quarterback that went 4-10 for 34 yards and one INT.
by Big Sky Bengal on Mar 21, 2010 5:13 PM EDT up reply actions
It's hard for me to be impressed by a QB that can't win a playoff game.
At least Unibrow has 3 under his belt.
It’s hard for me to be impressed when reasonable football discussion devolves into trash talking before even the DRAFT.
You should drink 5 hour energy
Tons of energy now
No emotional discharge later.
Please register for this great American football RPG through this link:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/signup.pl?ref=34554501
by Baltimore Warrior on Mar 22, 2010 3:49 PM EDT up reply actions
This is the internet, when is there not trash talking?
AFC North Rankings(before the draft):
1)Steelers – When healthy, they’re the best team in our division.(Troy is the best defender in football when healthy)
2)Ravens(Homer pick) – Bengals do have our numbers, but you’re inconsistent overall.
3) Bengals – Great running game. Solid D. If Carson Palmer returns to form watch out.
4) Browns – Who’s their QB?
I like this guy
With the 18th pick of the 2010 NFL Draft the Pittsburgh Steelers select Florida QB Tim Tebow. (not a RB!)
Yeah
I think he’s okay too and his rankings were pretty good.
I wish WE had the "Groundhog"....
Please register for this great American football RPG through this link:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/signup.pl?ref=34554501
by Baltimore Warrior on Mar 22, 2010 3:50 PM EDT up reply actions
Carson has a Questionable heart?
How many last minute drives did he pull together for us last year? His heart shouldn’t be in question – the arm is a small question mark though.
This is our year!
by Carsonorbust on Mar 21, 2010 6:39 PM EDT up reply actions
Don't underestimate
His off hand. It prevented him from selling the play action. Which was huuuge with how good of a running game we have.
RIP Slim.
by brandone on Mar 21, 2010 8:15 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
Various thoughts
“…her negotiation segments on Hard Knocks with Andre Smith still gives me horrifying nightmares.”
I think that’s why we can’t seem to negotiate with more than one FA at a time: Katie has to be there to ask, wide-eyed as a casual fan, why they need so much money.
And, man, Hobson looks rough. I don’t envy him; trying to force the company line to make sense must be a soul-crushing job.
We’ve had an okay offseason so far. I’d put it a little closer to being good than bad. As ever, we’ll need a great draft to keep up with the Joneses…and, as ever, I’m hoping our lone scout and scouting assistants are up to it.
DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT
the Ravens and Steelers have done for years what Marvin Lewis has been trying to do all along. Build your team through the draft. So it seems, Holmgren intends to do just that in Cleveland as well.
Year after year you watch teams that spend big money in Free Agency not winning Super Bowls….(the Redskins come to mind….but even the year the Patriots opened the check book to snag Audalius Thomas, Randy Moss, Wes Welker and Donte Stallworth, they still came up 1 short)
If you draft in a systematic approach, you only sign free agents as band-aids.
With the loss of Henry, and a Salary cap opportunity to dispose of Coles, Antonio Bryant upgrades that position. (More and more I’m liking this guy’s lunch-pale ethic, and I think Antonio Bryant fits this division really really well, can’t wait to see him catch one over the middle) Also, The TANK was a 1-year experiment…that went quite well. So you give that guy some cash and keep that position group stacked (since it is the most important position group on a football team).
But right now, the Bengals are fielding quite a many draft picks of their own. (Geathers, Peko, Michael Johnson, Leon and JJ, Rey and Rivers, Fanene, Rucker, Whitworth, Ocho, Caldwell, Bernard Scott, Chinedum Ndukwe, Andre The Giant and Anthony Collins……and for the love of god please don’t forget PAT SIMS).
With several picks gone awry, it really wasn’t until 2009 that you started to see the fruits of Marvin’s labor. Look for 06 through 09 draft picks to make a bigger impact in 2010, while the new draft picks are given an opportunity to grow and not be heavily relied upon right out of the gate.
(If your looking for 2nd – 5th round rookies to make an instant impact, we’re probably in trouble. That’s why i really can’t stand to hear Chase Coffman called a bust as a rookie 3rd round pick. Let’s at least wait to see how his sophomore year goes before we class him with @rome089)
(YES there are plenty of second-chancers on this squad, but give a scrooge a chance to save a dime and he will. But I don’t hear anyone complaining when Cedric Benson’s smashing through the LOS….or THE TANK is flattening fools on a TFL.)
Who Dey 2010…..here’s to sticking to the good old fashioned AFCN style. Smashmouth Football.
3 yards and a pile of dust
Anyone who can compare adding Antonio Bryant
To Anquan Boldin is just plain delirious. Anquan Boldin has had consistent years over and over regardless of his injuries where as Antonio has had 1 maybe 2 good seasons. You over payed a number 2 reciever at best. Secondly Stallworth is not troubled he just got unlucky I mean anyone crossing a 4 lane highway is asking to get run over. No one in this division has come close to the Ravens in upgrading this offseason.
by BitterYetDieHard on Mar 22, 2010 9:54 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
But then again,
what were they saying about Coles last year? Still, I’ll take Bryant over Bolden any day (and both over Coles). And good for Cincy letting the free agency play out. And c’ya Golden Graham. Glad that next year when the game with the Raves goes down to the wire, it’s we who sigh relief rather than hold our breaths when you line up for a kick that will go wide right.
Cincy is compose to make a deep run in 2010 "IF"
Carson Palmer is 110% healthy all year long,they have improve on Offensive and have a solid running game with Benson & Leonard & Scott,and I feel that Coffman will come to play this year & they should draft a tightend in the second round. SO Carson will have a lot of weapons on offensive to help him. But he needs to take control of offensive and run the no huddle 65% of the time I am sure that Chad/Bryant/Caldwell would LOVE that!.

by 


















