Will the Bengals' Passing Game Be Better in 2010? Probably, and here's why:
I know we've been over the merits of signing Antonio Bryant and drafting TE Jermaine Gresham and WR Jordan Shipley here at Cincy Jungle in stories, FanPosts, and comments ad nauseum. But at the root of the passing game is Carson Golden Arm Palmer. A look at some of Palmer's splits indicates that opposing defenses last year had an easy time game-planning for the Bengals offense, Bob Bratkowski aside, simply due to talent at skill positions.
In his best year (2005), Palmer was a 71.3% percent passer between the numbers. Last year, he sported a roughly 68.5% completion rate. In 2005, he averaged 7.8 yards per attempt; in 2009, 7.63 per attempt. Not a major difference, but his '09 rate was buoyed by several big plays down the middle of the field. The difference between his efficiency in 2005 and 2009 came down the sidelines, probably because that's where opposing coordinators focused a vast majority of their secondary defense. In '05, Palmer spread his interceptions fairly evenly around the field and most of his picks came on deeper routes, compared with 30% of his interceptions in 2009 resulting from short throws. Carson threw 76 less passes to the sidelines this year, and when he forced the ball to Chad Ochocinco on the right sideline, 7% of his passes were intercepted. Compare that to the rest of the field, where only 1% of his passes were picked, and you've got a pretty significant pattern.
Opposing secondaries gave up the middle of the field consistently last year, when Palmer was inefficient just about every where else, because there was only one dangerous receiving threat on the football field - Chad Ochocinco. Interestingly, Cedric Benson found most of his success to the outside, but was strikingly stuffed more frequently to the right side. Part of this has to do with offensive linemen (the RT situation last year was less than ideal), but it may also indicate a propensity for opposing defenses to have safety help cheating toward Ocho's side of the field, putting them in better position to disrupt the backfield. Additionally, opposing defenses seemed more likely to devote their front 7 to stopping Benson than dropping back in pass coverage due to a general dearth of TE or slot capability. It's hard to tell from the numbers whether or not the Bengals' offense adjusted to these tendencies late in the year, but the offense definitely faded down the stretch - can we blame Bratkowski for that?
Defenses facing the Bengals could quickly identify Laveranues Coles' ineffectiveness and seemed to gameplan that way. It was also pretty clear that Dan Coats (the worst, in fact, according to Football Outsiders) was a terrible receiver, and JP Foschi (who plays essentially at replacement-level production) were not contributing to the offense. Andre Caldwell had a promising first half, but after opposing teams ostensibly devoted better resources to covering him or identified a weakness, he was fairly unproductive down the stretch.
So, why will this year be different? For one thing, we can expect the offensive line to protect Palmer a bit better. They've been together for a year, Andre Smith, Nate Livings and Kyle Cook will show improvement, and Bobbie Williams and Andrew Whitworth will be the solid veterans we expect them to be. The hope is that Cook will become more efficient at identifying pass rushers and Andre Smith will be more effective on the right edge than Collins and Roland were last year.
The second important factor is the injection of new personnel. Jordan Shipley flashes immense talent over the middle of the field, drawing comparisons to Wes Welker as a route technician and skilled catcher of the football. Gresham should be leaps and bounds better than the combined efforts of Coats and Foschi last year, and there's a strong possibility that Chase Coffman will contribute to the offense after taking a year to redshirt, learn the offense, and learn how to play in-line. The other guy, Antonio Bryant, has simply been more effective than Coles for his entire career. He's an excellent downfield threat, and in his last full season caught 42% of his passes more than 10 yards down the field. He also shows exceptional ability to get open along the sidelines, something the Bengals sorely lacked last year.
Taken together, what you have is a classic example of an offense that will be greater than the sum of its parts. Last year, it was limited severely by a lack of personnel to execute any offensive game plan, regardless of how well or poorly Bratkowski may have drawn it up. Jermaine Gresham alone will command safety attention in the middle of the field. Antonio Bryant should alleviate some pressure from Chad Ochocinco. When you consider the possibility of Shipley (or a competition-inspired Caldwell) contributing from the slot and Coffman's potential production, things seem much more promising.
Ultimately, this year's offense rides on Carson Palmer's shoulders. He should have better protection. He has at least 2 new weapons, and perhaps 2 improved options as well. We'll learn this year whether Palmer's inaccuracy last year was a product of the team around him, or if his skills physically and mentally have deteriorated. Hopefully we'll see a quarterback this year that has time to go through his progression and doesn't have to fling the ball with a prayer toward Chad on the right side of the field. Another second or so (maybe even half a second) of time to find guys that should be more open and more reliable than last year's targets should go a long way in opening up the passing game.
18 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
2 TEs
I have a feeling unless we find a stud fullback via free agency or from some other avenue, we will use alot of two TE sets. I think Gresham can be a servicable blocker and hopefully with a year of seasoning Coffman can contribute as well. Now the fun would be begin if the offense could still be effective running the ball without a fullback. Having Coffman, Gresham, Ocho and Bryant on the field would give opposing defenses a lot of matchup issues. Hopefully we can find the play action passing game that was so succesful in the mid 2000’s. Either way I cant wait to see how Bob uses his new tools (puh puh puh please dont suck Bob)!!!!!
WHO DEY!!!!!
Excellent analysis.
One of the CBS analysts had mentioned that Carson was throwing more off his back foot than he had in the past. I am hoping that his decreased production was due more to a mechanical problem and a lack of options rather than to a diminishment in his skills. Your analysis has given me good reason to view the upcoming season with newly found optimism.
I noticed all season that Carson was forcing the ball to Chad. It wasn’t until the last 3 games that I realized that he was forcing it to Chad because everyone else had become ineffective, while earlier in the season Henry scared defenses enough to allow Caldweel and Coles to get open. The added wapons should help Carson and Cedric return to a potent offense.
+1
He definitely forced the ball towards Chad. The play that sticks in my mind is the playoff pick to Revis. Revis was in better position than Chad but Carson new he had to try and make a play. That shouldn’t be the case this year.
Carson had "happy feet"
all year long. Being light on your feet is good, but he looked like a rookie QB the way he jitterbugged sometimes.
Anyone else notice?
Yea
I noticed sometimes. I think there was a greater affect on Carson losing TJ. I think TJ was his “security blanket” and when in trouble he would count on TJ to make a play. He hasn’t found that comfort with anyother receivers. In fact he hasn’t came close. Hopefully another year without TJ and the extra receivers and TE’s that we have brought in will allow him to feel more comfortable with his receivers. I also think that he didn’t trust the line last year. That being said he should have a bounce back year. Hopefully another year will allow him to get over the injuries he has received, the new players on the line, receivers not getting open, Brat’s playcalling, and the trust of the receivers that I explained above. In one way or another all of this should see improvement. .
Preseason is the key
Remember last year the o-line was in flux. For the first preseason game they only a had base protection scheme down and Palmer ended up missing most of the preseason with a high ankle injury.
He never had a chance for any game relationship with his receivers except what he carried over with Chad and 85. Caldwell had played sparingly before. Then we lost Henry.
This year he has a new receiving corp again. And that’s why we can’t mess with the o-line. He can’t afford to miss preseason time to get game comfortable with Bryant, Gresham, Coffman, maybe Shipley, etc. in live action.
well said
and that’s not even mentioning what Dezmon Briscoe or Matt Jones might bring as a deep threats, both with size advantages.
by IgnatiusJReilly on Apr 30, 2010 5:41 PM EDT reply actions
I expect that they'll be used somewhat sparingly.
They’re only going to see time in 4-WR packages for the most part unless Bryant or Ocho go down with injury.
does anyone think
Jones makes this team? I don’t see it happening.
I'm not going to say he definitely makes it but....
I think he has a legitimate shot. I could see him making the team. I could also see him not making the team so…. If he shows the physical talent that he is capable of then he has a great chance to make the team. It may also come down to if the Bengals keep 5 or 6 Receivers. Jones offers something a little different then any of the other Receivers with his speed and size. Marvin has already said he wants more “big plays” from the Offense. I thinkJones has the potential to make those plays. That being said it is probably the toughest position battle this preseason. If he performs in Training Camp and preseason then he will make the team. Bottom line is he has a good shot of making the team, IMO He has to earn it though with his play on the field. One thing that will hurt him is his Special Teams play. He doesn’t offer much in this area compared to Cosby, Shipley, and unfortunately even Caldwell
If Shipley returns punts, Jones has a shot. Chad, Bryant,and Shipley are locks. Caldwell and Briscoe have inside leads. Their is one spot left for Cosby, Simpson, Jones or other. If Cosby returns punts the spot is his, plus you have to love his special teams contributions.
Oh thats if they keep 6
They may only keep 5 though they kept 6 last year. I would think they would keep 6 but no guarantee. I agree with you analysis for the most part. I say Simpson is probably already a little behind Cosby and Jones, though. I think he has to come out and play exceptional. Even if he outplays both Cosby and Jones he is likely to still get cut. I would say its going to come down to Cosby and Jones barring any injuries. I could see it going either way….. Can’t wait!
true but...
That may be where the some big plays come from so…. whoever is in there needs to be able to get open and I think our receivers this year have a better chance of doing that then the ones we had last year.
Great insight .....Missing the point
Great stuff Jake
So many fail to see all the intricacy’s that go into a productive passing attack. Then theres the faction that insist on a power running attack. If you have both you probably have a Super Bowl trophy or two.
The points that the article touched on are all great points and factors in the deficiency’s of the offense last season. Basically having one receiver that could beat single coverage (Chad) last season doomed the Bengals to the result.
Strangely I see all the TV talking points cited from posters above. These points were short sighted analysis that never took into account the entire scope of the problems. Yet the fan base drinks the koolaide by the gallons.
1. Palmer forced the ball to 85.
His chances most of the time were better trying to beat double covered 85 than wasting an incompletion or worse throwing to his other options He at no time choose that tendency of his own free will. That was his option period.
2. Throwing off his back foot.
How many times and why did he do that. Carson Palmer has one of the best techniques of any QB in the league. They all throw all their back foot from time to time. if you put three more valid options on the field CP can throw from his knee’s and complete passes
Happy feet.
Your kiddin…They had him roll out by design most of the season due to the door being open on the right side of the line. With the injury history and traffic he had in the pocket ..you’d have happy feet to.
Lack of time to jell.
Didn’t Caldwell, Simpson and Henry go to Calif. and workout with Palmer over the winter.
Experiance sure could help but a few of these guys need to work on their own to improve their individual skills. Most of em can’t beat single coverage, break up an interception or catch the ball a lot of times. Thats not to say this new group will fare any better…but it looks promising. Preseason is more important to the line.
Fullbacks the problem.
Half the teams in the league rarely use a fullback. If you field enough talent to keep a defense honest. They cant triple team your only receiver. They can’t stack the line with eight people to deny the rush. chase you out of the pocket because you hold the ball so long.
A good receiving team opens holes for the run….because everyones a threat . A great fullback is a threat. He has to be an offensive threat like Leonard has been though. A blocking back might be effective on 4th and goal. Short of that they draw more attention to the run than they’re worth. A lot of times the mere sight of a Fullback spell run.
All the troubleshooting above is directly related to the issues the writer pointed out. They all cure themselves with the balance gained from closing the personnel holes at TE, WR , RT.
I hope they’ve addressed the problems in this article….Because those are the problems with The Bengals offense..
Personally I think if Matt Jones applies himself he won’t have nuch of a problem making this team. He’s still young and his abilities are greater than all the competition in his skill area. hopefully he’s worked like hell over the winter or he won’t make it. With his past…. The hurdle is a little higher than the others.
65 catches and 47 1st downs in 08 in only twelve games….are eye opening to a team with the possesion problems we had last season. I don’t care who does it really. We’ve all seen the proof of second chances on this team though….

by 

























