Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Drug Testing, Alistair Overeem & UFC 146's Potential Legacy

Will Robert Geathers And/Or Antwan Odom Be With The Bengals When The Regular Season Starts?

Bengals defensive end Robert Geathers recorded 10.5 quarterback sacks during the 2006 season, mostly as a third down pass rushing specialist. On January 10, 2007, the Bengals rewarded Geathers with a six-year contract worth $33.75 million with $12.5 million guaranteed, with at least another $1.25 million linked to incentives with quarterback sacks and Pro Bowl berths. Geathers is projected to make $3.95 million in 2011.

A year later, on March 2, 2008, the Bengals signed free agent Antwan Odom with a five-year deal worth $29.5 million with $11.5 million guaranteed. Odom is projected to make $4.5 million in 2011.

Will either defensive end make the roster in 2011?

Star-divide

Geathers has played 58 regular season games since signing his contract in 2007, recording 10.5 quarterback sacks through the last four seasons -- the same total he recorded in 2006. In his three seasons with the Bengals, Antwan Odom has only played 46% of the team's games since 2008 (competing in 22 of a possible 48 games), recording 11 quarterback sacks during that stretch. Even that is somewhat misleading. If you take away his five-sack performance against the Green Bay Packers, that's six total quarterback sacks in 21 games played for the Bengals over three seasons.

Combined, Geathers and Odom will cost the Bengals $8.45 million in 2011.

During his position review of the defensive line, the Cincinnati Enquirer's Joe Reedy believes that only one of the team's veteran defensive ends will return next season.

Along with Geathers and Odom, Carlos Dunlap, Frostee Rucker and Michael Johnson are signed through 2011 (among other noteworthy linemen like Victor Adeyanju and James Ruffin). Jonathan Fanene is an unrestricted free agent who the team likes for his versatility to play any position on the defensive line.

Even after the Collective Bargaining Agreement is resolved, the team will have decisions to make. One of those might be releasing either Geathers or Odom. On the other hand, with a new CBA means that releasing one of player could have a decent salary cap penalty upon release.

Then there's the question of the NFL draft. Will the team look to draft a defensive end, like Da'Quan Bowers to work opposite of Carlos Dunlap?

Based on production alone, it would make sense that the Bengals release either Geathers or Odom, if not both defensive ends. On the other hand, with so much unknown about the CBA (salary caps, penalties) the Bengals might keep both players for a slight comfort of depth at the position. Additionally, if the CBA is finally resolved two weeks before the projected start of the season, how likely would the team be to revamping their roster? In their mind, it might be the safest move keeping both ends on the roster who already know the defense.

Poll
What should the Bengals do?
Release Antwan Odom and Robert Geathers
251 votes
Release Antwan Odom but keep Robert Geathers
183 votes
Release Robert Geathers but keep Antwan Odom
107 votes
Keep both defensive ends
56 votes

597 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 14 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Tough call, let Zim handle it

I definitely don’t think they should keep both. Let Zimmer decide who stays and who goes. Maybe they both go if he doesn’t need them. I like Geathers because he’s a good tackler who can play special teams and be a rotational DE. He can also fill in at OLB if he really has to. Odom has been far more dominant at times in his career, but only here and there. I think it was the roids, but man was he effective sometimes.

Home of the original Kitten Mittens.

by Pardon_My_French on Feb 17, 2011 2:17 PM EST reply actions  

Both are overpriced back ups at this point.

Dunlap and Johnson have proved in my opinion to be more effective. Geathers and Odom have had their best days and have both proved to be injury prone. To me this is the most obvious position on the team to free up a lot of cap space without downgrading in talent. Draft someone in the middle to help the young ends we already have and add depth with FA and late round, high end prospects. Geathers had one good year and Odom has had one good third of a year for this team. Neither have been worth the money they’ve been paid and to keep paying them for minimal production would be dumb as we need this money to keep J-Joe and L-Hall around.

by JamesShively on Feb 17, 2011 2:21 PM EST reply actions  

Agree on Odom

But I think that Geathers is good on first and second down, allowing Dunlop to maximize opportunities in passing situations, making him more effective.

It must be inordinately taxing to be such a boob. ~ The Brain

by jim0ijk on Feb 17, 2011 3:56 PM EST up reply actions  

I know one thing for sure

Dunlap should be starting

"You don't live in Cleveland, You live in Cincinnati"-Sam Wyche
"I promise to throw interceptions for touchdowns just as good as he did" -Jordan Palmer

by TennBengalfan on Feb 17, 2011 2:44 PM EST reply actions   1 recs

Keep Geathers, Release Odom. Sign Ray Edwards

Geathers, if you notice, actually lines up at DT on obvious passing downs. L to R (at the end of last year when we seem to generate most of the pass rush) it was Dunlap, Geathers, Big Geno, and MJ. So Geathers is still a productive player, and Zim seems to appreciate all of the little things he does and brings to the table. Keep him. Plus, although it seems he’s been around forever (drafted in 2004), Geathers is only 27.

Regarding Odom, he should be released (I.e. Contract terminated). He simply cannot stay healthy enough to be a constant presence on the field for an entire season.

Use the money saved by releasing Antwan (plus money saved from an eventual Chad trade) to sign Vikings DE (and Cincinnati native) Ray Edwards. Edwards has admitted he’d like to play in Cincinnati if everything is right (read: the contract and guaranteed money is what he expects).

2011 DEs = Geathers, Dunlap, MJ, Ray Edwards (hopefully), Frostee, and Fanene (re-sign him, plus Fanene is versatile enough to also play DT.).

DT = Domata, Geno, Sims, Tank/draft pick

by The_Black_Stripes on Feb 17, 2011 3:43 PM EST via mobile reply actions  

I'm not for signing Edwards

If we let the old guys go, we might as well hand things over to the young guys.

by The Dealio on Feb 17, 2011 3:46 PM EST up reply actions  

Edwards is NOT old

He just turned 26, and is coming off his rookie contract. Believe me, Zim will be able to get all DLinemen plenty of snaps. Plus, you can never have enough quality pass rushers (just ask the SB winning NY Giants from 2007).

by The_Black_Stripes on Feb 17, 2011 4:16 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

Not so fast that team had Strahan who made the difference not just a good pass rush look what the team minus him did!

by ashunte23 on Feb 17, 2011 4:58 PM EST up reply actions  

Giants also had . . .

Osi, Justin Tuck, Mathias Kiwanuka, Strahan. Those are/were four dominant and relentless pass rushers. Also, Osi suffered a severe injury the year after the Giants won the SB, so it wasn’t just Strahan’s retirement that hurt (pun intended) them.

2007 Giants of Osi, Tuck, Strahan, and Kiwanuka could be duplicated by . . .

2011 Bengals of Michael Johnson, Dunlap, Geathers, and Ray Edwards (hopefully). They would all see significant snap, while still keeping them all fresh.

by The_Black_Stripes on Feb 17, 2011 5:08 PM EST via mobile up reply actions  

Keep Geathers for depth, drop Odom. I guarantee Odom will get hurt again. Roids made him a beast and he only looked good in 09

Roids made him (Odom) a beast and he only looked good in 09 because of the 5 sack games against GB. GB had Oline problems that day. Odom got lucky…

by cincity8285 on Feb 17, 2011 3:44 PM EST reply actions  

Perfect example

Of MB s thriftyness. You reap what you sew

by quickslant on Feb 17, 2011 3:45 PM EST via mobile reply actions  

Odom is overpaid,

as well as sickly. He always looks like he just recovered from a major illness, and he gets hurt a lot. I would bet he’s missed more games than he’s played but I don’t know the numbers. He needs to go.

Bengals Next Step (BNS)

by BonnieBengal on Feb 17, 2011 5:36 PM EST reply actions  

If we draft Bowers, get rid of both

If not, keep Geathers at the least. Geathers, as injured as he has been, gets on the field, but I imagine Bowers fully assimilating Geathers’ role on this defense if he is drafted by us.

by Doc Scratch on Feb 17, 2011 6:14 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Cincinnati Bengals.

Editor-In Chief

Cj_small Josh Kirkendall

Editor/Managing Editor

Rudiblanket_small Anthony Cosenza

5255_133614603784_666578784_2414703_1976100_n_small Jason Garrison

Authors

Photo_3_small BeerRun

010511170110_small Joe Goodberry

40297_422933299865_509514865_4658259_6466915_n_small Ryan Harper

Small Brennen Warner

Sb_nation_small Jack Cassidy

580551_10150822857707018_613867017_11694254_1239726425_n_small Nick_Crago

Img_0783_small Mike Fightmaster

Moderators

Nfl palewook

680764146_0eac16fabd_small 80%OFTHETIMEIMRIGHTEVERYTIME

Tawky_tawny_small UpStateMike

Joeb698_86e260_small joeb69

Bengals_stamp_by_jamaal10_small Doc Scratch