Does Corey Dillon Belong in the Bengals Hall of Fame?
That's a good question. On one hand, he did some amazing things while he was in a Bengals uniform. He is the Bengals all-time leading rusher. He broke the single game rushing record, previously held by Walter Peyton, while in stripes when he ran for 278 yards against the Broncos in 2000.
On the other hand, though, he left Cincinnati on such a sour note, and most Bengals fans were glad to be rid of him, especially after the emergence of Rudi Johnson.
The voice of the mothership, Geoff Hobson, posed the question on Monday. Dillon, along with many other former Bengals, including Jeff Blake, are on the ballot for you to vote them into the Bengals Hall of Fame.
The criteria for being inducted into the hall of fame is as follows:
Players must be retired from the NFL for five seasons and must have spent at least one season as a Bengal to be eligible for the ballot that includes multiple Pro Bowlers, career record-holders, and at-large candidates. Coaches are eligible at any time, but must no longer be with the club. Quarterback Jeff Blake, who went from the waiver wire to the Pro Bowl with a ball that was as long as the odds of a sixth-rounder, made this year's ballot as an at-large candidate.
Hobson mentions that Bengals founder Paul Brown and greatest player Anthony Muñoz were the first two people to be inducted into the hall of fame. The main question is this: does Dillon's name belong on the same wall as Brown and Muñoz.
Dillon's appearance could take more votes away from the older generation, but his candidacy is intriguing. The numbers say he's a lock with a Bengals-record 8,061 yards carved out on some of the worst teams in franchise history on an angry 4.3 yards per carry that battered defenders.
But his chip-on-the-shoulder intensity bubbled off the field and it's fascinating to see how the fans respond to him in the voting booth. The 278-yard game, in which he ripped off touchdown runs of 65 and 41 yards in the fourth quarter, and his NFL rookie-record 246 yards almost got as much ink as his tirades.
Some of the other names on the list include: Cris Collinsworth, Max Montoya, Carl Pickens, Dan Ross, Bob Trumpy, Sam Wyche and Tremain Mack.
As for me, while I agree that Dillon deserves to be on the list, I'd have a hard time voting for him over names like Collinsworth, Wyche, Ross or Trumpy. I enjoyed watching Dillon when he played, but his attitude, especially in the latter part of his career in Cincinnati left a bad taste in my mouth.
You can vote for who you feel should be inducted into the Bengals hall of fame here.
28 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I think one should ask themselves the question
“Would this player see this as an honor?” With Dillion I say no. I feel if he was informed he was inducted in to our Hall of Fame, he may just laugh it off as if he didn’t care either way. I think Carson Palmer down the road will give me the same impression.. So no.. I don’t want him in. If they’re not proud of being a Cincinnati Bengal then why enshrine them as one forever?
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 4:11 PM EDT reply actions 3 recs
Rec'd
"You don't live in Cleveland, You live in Cincinnati"-Sam Wyche
"I promise to throw interceptions for touchdowns just as good as he did" -Jordan Palmer
by TennBengalfan on Mar 30, 2011 8:04 AM EDT up reply actions
Corey Dillon was the Best of the 1990's
If we won a game.. IT was Corey Dillon winning it.
In his tenure between 97-03 He made 3 Pro Bowls.
Why is that such a feat? 7-9, 3-13, 4-12, 4-12, 6-10, 2-14, 8-8 Records with him here but the offensive play maker still got Pro Bowl nods.
Look at the stat’s during his Bengal tenure, he was a monster on a horrible team.
Plain and simple there isn’t a Bengals running back out there I would choose OVER Corey Dillon. Brooks was good, Rudi good, and Ced’s fine. But I don’t remember any of them having their cleats in the H.O.F.
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
And while some of his gear is in the H.O.F.
It was also thrown at Cincinnati fans (out of disrespect) upon his return to Paul Brown Stadium as a New England Patriot.
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 4:31 PM EDT up reply actions
He got burnt out in cincinnati
I don’t blame him one bit.
We’re the same franchise that’s making Palmer want out.
That doesn’t mean he wasn’t one of the best Bengals to ever play running back.
And in fact, tell me who was better?
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
Naw.
I like James.
But Corey was 5x better (notice I only said 5 not 10 or 100)
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
I admired the guy just as much as you.
I can remember being the happiest 13 year old kid in the world when I got the new alternate orange Corey Dillon jersey for Christmas. Only to have him spew a bunch of garbage at the team, city and later directly insulting the fans that supported him. Sorry it’s not just about stats to me. He wouldn’t be honored to have it anyways. Obviously in your eyes and with great reasoning, he is the Barry Sanders of the Bengals in the 90’s. Barry similarly wanted out because he didn’t like the organization he’d been working for. I understand that, and by no means blame Barry for that. The difference is attacking the entire city and the fans of that team because of the organization. How can you drink kool-aid to the point that someone has made a personal attack on a fan base your apart of? Even in Chad or Carson situation they have never attacked the fans but more so the organization. He is not Barry Sanders to me in anyway shape or form.
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 5:27 PM EDT up reply actions
If he hates Cincinnati or not
It can’t change who the Franchise rushing leader is right?
Yea he left Cincinnati pretty bad, I admit it.
Take this from a Cavaliers guy, just because he left on a major sour note it doesn’t change what he did when he was here. Hate how he left and his actions towards the city after he left your team but it doesn’t take away what he did during his tenure. It doesn’t change the fact that he was phenomenal on the field. It doesn’t change the fact that he wasn’t the one glimmer of hope the team had during the majority of his tenure.
To let the actions of what he did when he WASN’T a Bengal or on his way out the door have a bigger impact on your decision then his play is taking it too far. Unless he actually came out and specifically said “f^ck James Shively” it’s time to move on man time has passed, and he’s not even in the league anymore.
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
Sorry I agree to disagree with you..
As a fan base it would make us look weak minded to enshrine a guy in our H.O.F. that basically spit on us in his return to our stadium. He basically said F*ck you Bengal fans.. I’m a Bengals fan.. In a way he said F*ck you to anyone who is.. I’d put Ickey Woods in over this schmuck…
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 6:07 PM EDT up reply actions
Question
So when he returned? Did the entire stadium embrace him and basically applaud him like when McNabb came back to Philly?
Or did they do the.. ‘we hate you, you always sucked and we don’t miss you’ routine?
For some reason.. I don’t see PBS embracing an ex player too well..
Nor really have never seen it gone well for when I was at the games.
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
If there was a sour response from the fans at PBS.
It was brought on by himself by the way he openly talked shit to the media about their favorite team. Players get booed at PBS because the openly talk shit about the city. I’d be willing to bet if Chad comes back next year playing against us he’ll get a McNabb like response. He had his problem but he has embraced Cincinnati as his own for years and will likely get treated the same once he leaves.
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 6:32 PM EDT up reply actions
Brought on or not before the game
He reacted to the environment around him. If they were neutral or even semi-embraced him you could make a case. but to flat out say
spit on us in his return to our stadium. He basically said F*ck you Bengal fans..
And ignore the fact that Paul Brown Stadium was already going off on him, your leaving off a key part of the equation.
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
We just disagree about this plain and simple.
I don’t believe in enshrining someone to a H.O.F. of a team that they demanded to not be apart of. If they had done what Chad has done and returned with an open heart and mind maybe. Corey Dillon no. Carl Pickens no. Carson Palmer is still in the air but I have a feeling my answer for him in the future will be no. Enshrining Corey Dillon to our H.O.F. would be like the Eagles enshrining Terrell Owens. Makes us look like a bunch of kool-aid drinking idiots that can’t tell disrespect when we its been shoved down our throats.
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 7:18 PM EDT up reply actions
To be fair
Enshrining Corey Dillon to our H.O.F. would be like the Eagles enshrining Terrell Owens.
He didn’t get drafted by the eagles and solely carry the team on his back. And Carson probably shouldn’t be because he never won a playoff game; when Ken and Boomer have. Not because he wants out.
I mean he left in a bad note yea. But I mean like i can compare this to Lebron and Cleveland, I have no doubt even after everything happened and how much I personally dislike him. Lebron deserves to be in the Cav HOF.
Makes us look like a bunch of kool-aid drinking idiots that can’t tell disrespect when we its been shoved down our throats.
That happened years ago. It’s ok to move on, step back and say “He made some big contributions to this team and deserves to be recognized.” To hold onto the anger like that and say he doesn’t deserve to be recognized as one of the better bengals to play in stripes is petty.
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
This guy is not gonna change his opinion....
he would rather keep someone out of the Bengals HOF for something they said rather than putting then in based on actual on field accomplishments.
Nothing new. People hold grudges over comments more so than countries do against other countries that bomb them. Why waste your time with someone with petty grievances.
Slower Traffic Keep Right!
Actions speak louder than words right?
Throwing your equipment at people that have supported you is kind of shitty actions..
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 8:12 PM EDT up reply actions
Since you like qouting me I'll do the same.
I don’t believe in enshrining someone to a H.O.F. of a team that they demanded to not be apart of.
by JamesShively on Mar 29, 2011 7:50 PM EDT up reply actions
I dont know the criteria etc....Hell I didnt even know the Bengals had an HOF
If Corey Dillon had played for a serious franchise his whole career I believe he would have been an NFL Hall of Famer. He had to endure terrible coaches, management and poor personnel.
I could care less if he ended up with a sour attitude here. I would have to and I can’t understand how anyone could fault him for wanting out. No one on the team or the coaching staff was ever held accountable for poor play. All Corey did was come out and run into a brick wall every game. He tried his best even though the rest of the franchise could care less.
He will always be one of my favorite Bengals b/c he was a bad ass and I witnessed him set 2 NFL rushing records in person. The man was a beast.
Slower Traffic Keep Right!
Dillon Deserves It
Dillon was the only reason Cincy was even on the map, during a 5-year period. I don’t think any other canidate can say that.
I wouldn't vote for dillon.
Now folks like filched
by quickslant on Mar 29, 2011 6:20 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
Fulcher and the others aforementioned, I would. How about Rodney?
by quickslant on Mar 29, 2011 6:23 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
The ballot is kinda funny
You have to vote for exactly 10 players lol
No More No Less or else you ballot doesn’t count.
1st round draft wishes.
Bengals: Blaine Gabbert, Marcell Dareus or AJ Green!
Cavaliers: ANY PG AND SF DUO.
www.FearTheSword.com.
I just think there should be other players voted in ahead of him
I would rather have Ickey voted in before him just because of the shuffle
"You don't live in Cleveland, You live in Cincinnati"-Sam Wyche
"I promise to throw interceptions for touchdowns just as good as he did" -Jordan Palmer

by 





























