John Thornton: Jordan Palmer Is "Way Ahead" Of The Other Bengals Quarterbacks
Jordan Palmer has attempted only 15 passes in his three-year NFL career, posting ten completions for 59 yards passing, two touchdowns, four picks and a career quarterback rating of 34.4. Andy Dalton is the team's second round draft pick during the 2011 NFL Draft and expected long-term solution after Jordan's older brother Carson demanded a trade or else he'll retire; not returning no matter what is what we're hinting at here.
Dan LeFevour, signed off waivers by the Bengals on September 5 last year, rounds out the team's quarterbacks. Like Dalton, LeFevour has no pass attempts in his NFL career.
One of our most important questions when it comes to the Bengals this summer (and eventually fall), will be the quarterback situation. Until free agency begins at the start of the new league year, the Bengals will have to choose between Jordan Palmer, Andy Dalton and Dan LeFevour.
That being said, of those already on the team, former Bengals defensive tackle John Thornton believes that "Jordan Palmer is way ahead of the" rest of the quarterbacks.
As I said on here before, Jordan looks the part. He just doesn’t have the game experience. But I liked what I saw from him. He can make every throw and loves taking shots downfield. Andy Dalton looked good but he threw too many check downs, so it was hard for me to judge him as a drop back QB. He needs time to get used to things and not having the benefit of the spread offense. He was comfortable with the guys though, so that will help him. QB Dan LeFevour was out there as well. This is my first time seeing him in person. I was standing and watching with his college coach, Butch Jones, so I got some good insight on what kind of guy he is. Smart, instinctive, good leader. I hear he’s been working really hard this offseason. Looked ok out there as well, but hard to tell without having DL rushing.
26 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
This is getting interesting....
What do you do when there's no way out? Find a way to get deeper in it.
until..
they have to make quick decisions against opponents in a real NFL game there’s no way to know. Jordan is the only one that’s done that in his life, and even he only in garbage time.
We’ll see. Hopefully someone steps up.
Matt Hasselbeck
I think Hasselbeck would be a good fit here in Cincinnati. His father is from the area so he enjoys and respects the city as a whole. On top of that he’s a perfect stop gap to give Dalton a year or two to sit and watch. He knows the west coast offense so he would catch on to Jay Gruden’s offense relatively quick. I’d like to see Matt in stripes for a year or two. Good fit for Cincinnati.
What happens when and if we pick up a Vet?
do we carry 4 quarterbacks until we figure out which one of the young guys is the worst, or keep all 4 until the vet leaves? Do we just let LeFevour go without even knowing what he can do? I’m very curious about how this situation will play out
Nobody in football should be called a genius... A genius is a guy like Norman Einstein.
by ItsAlwaysSunnyInDayton on Jun 16, 2011 3:06 PM EDT up reply actions
Cut J.Palmer as a screw you statement to Carson.
Run Dalton as your second string and keep developing LeFevour.
by JamesShively on Jun 16, 2011 4:12 PM EDT up reply actions
You'd cut the apparent best QB on the team just as an insult to his brother?
Regardless of what Palmer’s done, that’s kind of stupid, isn’t it?
Not if you're planning on signing someone like Hasselbeck...
Palmer gave the middle finger to the franchise… It’s a perfect way for the franchise to give it right back to him..
by JamesShively on Jun 16, 2011 4:59 PM EDT up reply actions
>Hasselbeck
You mean the guy who played in like half of the Seahawks’ games last season? You okay with throwing Dalton or LeFevour out there on week two or three because Hasselbeck got injured?
Yup Hasselbeck gives us a better shot than anyone else.
Your assuming he’ll be injured by the second week of the season. Which is very unlikely.
by JamesShively on Jun 16, 2011 7:51 PM EDT up reply actions
overrated and can't stay healthy
he’s managed to play in all 16 games 3 times in 12 years, most recently in 2007.
Yep, Hasselbeck is falling apart
Not sure what he got into at the end of last season, but it must have been voodoo or something because he hasn’t played consistently well for years. Smart guy, but his body is about done and his arm is average at best, and that’s being pretty generous. He’s even less impressive in person than he is on TV.
by stripesinseattle on Jun 17, 2011 12:42 AM EDT up reply actions
seriously?
That’s one of the dumbest things I’ve seen written on this site. These guys are adults that make their own decisions. Jordan may not make the team, but if the reason for that is anything other than he’s the worst QB we have, then MB is even worse than I thought. And I would have rated him #500 of 122 in the ESPN ranking, based on his smarts.
by stripesinseattle on Jun 17, 2011 12:47 AM EDT up reply actions
+1
This is the perfect scenario for 2011 and maybe even 2012. With the lockout-shortened offseason, they need an experienced guy from the WCO that can step in and control the offense from day 1. If they plan to be any kind of competitive in 2011, Hassleback should be made an offer.
Dalton isn’t ready and neither is LeFevour. Though I like both of them, they are one to two year projects and need a mentor. Jordan isn’t an NFL QB, period. Giving him the starting job would be a disaster—both in terms of the team’s development and the fact that his brother (the reason Jordan is even in Cincinnati) bailed on the team.
by Anthony Cosenza on Jun 16, 2011 4:35 PM EDT up reply actions
I think Jordan has to be the week 1 starter.
He has the most chemistry with the receivers. He has the most experience. He has the most developed NFL/Prostyle skillset. Let him take the reigns. Let Dalton sit and learn for at least half the season. Jordan was not a bad QB in college and he’s a much better fit for the WCO than he was for Brat’s vertical offense. He’s also smart, I’m positive he could at least get a handle on the offense in time to go.
All of this will be sorted at training camp, if we have one, and I really hope the FO will make the right call on who to start.
“I really hope the FO will make the right call on who to start”
shudder
by BlitzAway on Jun 16, 2011 4:03 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
unless they write it off as a rebuilding year..
they really need a veteran. Unless you believe Jordan is a real NFL qb, which seemed silly a year ago. Has anything really changed?
OK
John Thornton takes are always valuable. Johns take on the #1 Draft Pick came to frution. Cam Newton was the guy. Thornton said it first. If John says that Jordan Palmer is ’way ahead of the the other QBs" I for one will take Johns read to the bank!
It does not matter to cut Jordan Palmer or LeFevour
They are so bad that you can get both whenever you want (LeFevour to the PS and Palmer to replace the injured vet QB: Hasselbeck, Garcia,…)
Jordan Palmer Is “Way Ahead” Of The Other Bengals Quarterbacks
Wow, talk about a major insult to the other QB’s to say that Jordan Palmer is way better than you are. Ouch!!!
He might as well tell them that his grandma runs faster than them or that Steve Erkel is more manly than them while he’s at it.
We'd be stupid not to see what JP5 has in camp.
Ditto for More Cowbell as well.
Jordan may surprise us all when/if he gets a shot at camp. I don’t know that he has the chops, but it looks like this year we’ll see the absolute best he has to offer.
I have a feeling that Dan is not going to make it out of camp.

by 

























