Grading The 2011 Bengals: Linebackers
The 2011 Bengals linebackers were completely different from the 2010 linebackers. For one, middle linebacker Dhani Jones left the Bengals as a free agent, which caused the Bengals to move Rey Maualuga to the middle from outside. Also, outside linebacker Keith Rivers injured his wrist before the season and was played on the PUP list, which caused the Bengals front office to search the free agent market for a replacement.
They signed two free agent linebackers to play on either side of Rey Maualuga, Thomas Howard and Manny Lawson, and they both had solid seasons and helped the Bengals achieve another top-10 defensive ranking. The linebackers were a big part of the team's success but at times they also struggled, especially Maualuga.
Here are each linebackers' individual grades and the unit's grade as a whole.
Middle Linebacker Rey Maualuga: Maualuga had some good games and some terribly bad games. When the Bengals first played the Texans in Week 14, Maualuga single handedly gave the Bengals a chance at a win. He forced two fumbles, recovering one, on two great plays against one of the league's best running offenses. However, there were other games in which Maualuga looked lost and couldn't stop anybody. His ProFootballFocus.com run defense score was 2.7 but his pass coverage score was -5.7 and his pass rush score was -1.5 for a total grade of -6.3.
Outside Linebacker Thomas Howard: Howard had a good season in Cincinnati in 2011. He played so well that when Rivers came back from injury, the team placed him on IR instead of activating him. Howard had a run defense score of 0.7, a pass rushing score of -0.2 and a pass coverage score of 0.2. His overall score was 2.4.
Outside Linebacker Manny Lawson: Lawson took Maualuga's spot at outside linebacker when Rey moved to the middle to replace Jones. Lawson was impressive, especially when it came to run defense. He scored a score of 8.1 for run defense, a 1.1 for pass rushing and a -0.6 for pass defense for a total score of 10.6.
Outside Linebacker Brandon Johnson: Johnson was re-signed by the Bengals in the offseason and was used primarily in passing situations. He had a run defense score of 2.9, a pass rush score of -0.6 and a pass defense score of -2.8 for an overall grade of 0.5.
Middle Linebacker Dan Skuta: Skuta played as Maualuga's backup and started three games in the middle of the season when Rey was out with an ankle injury. Other than that he mostly played on special teams or special defensive packages. He had a run defense score of 2.9, a pass rush score of 2.7 and a coverage score of -3.2 for an overall grade of 2.5. He also had a special teams score of 1.0.
Outside Linebacker Vincent Rey: Rey only took two snaps as a linebacker in 2011 and didn't accumulate any stats. He did have an overall special teams score of 1.0, though.
While the Bengals' two starting outside linebackers, Howard and Lawson, both had good years, Maualuga was wildly inconsistent. He was a force in some games and he was really terrible in others. As a whole, the Bengals defensive front seven was very good and helped the defense keep the offense in a position to win the majority of their games and they were a big part of the team making it to the playoffs.
For their performance in the 2011 NFL season, the Bengals linebackers deserve a grade of B-/C+. What grade would you give them?
41 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
i thought howard's score would be higher
but other than that, nothing surprised me. i was in disbelief every time i heard people saying rey maualuga was having a pro bowl season (people said it many times, don’t remember who). he was by far our weakest link at linebacker.
Rey needs to step up for sure in 2012 or we will be talking about dafting another MLB next year
AMAS
yep. i'd say MLB is definitely a position that requires an offseason
this year, he gets one. if he doesn’t’ have a dramatic improvement, then the bengals need to look at getting a new MLB
If the guy doesn't start playing with his head
Then there isn’t going to be too much improvement. He plays out of control and doesnt rap when he tackles. All he wants to do is make the big hit instead of making the sure tackle. He’d rather throw his shoulder into a thigh instead of making the sure tackle to get off the field and getting the ball back to his offense.
by whodeycommish14 on Jan 24, 2012 4:52 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
can't afford to wait
We need to add a legit MLB via FA or the draft. Maualuga needs to earn his roster spot and I’m not convinced he can. The guy does a really poor job fighting off blocks. Linemen move him around and out of the play consistently. After 3 years of development if this is still a problem I think it will always be a problem. I also don’t see him as the leader of our defense. If the Bengals are going to build on the young talent and deliver a team that can win BIG games than they cannot afford to start 2012 with guys that are not leaders and not consistent forces at their position.
Yeah I still remember to this day
People calling Rey Maualuga the next Ray Lewis. Actually, I remember during the Cincinnati media having a conference call and asking Ray about the similarities. Ray was trying his hardest not to be mean, but deep down you could tell he was laughing.
by whodeycommish14 on Jan 24, 2012 4:47 PM EST via mobile reply actions
is Lawson a free agent?
Or is it Howard?
Rey is a disappointment so far. Keith Rivers as well. This franchise is doubly cursed by (a) spending more picks on linebackers in the first three rounds than any other position ( going back 20 years) and (b) not finding a dominant stud with any of those picks.
Attention Mike Brown: One-and-done doesn’t cut it. You will see more empty seats next year if you don’t show the fans you’re trying to win the Super Bowl!
by occams_tiger_teeth on Jan 24, 2012 4:49 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Howard signed a two year deal
Manny is a FA
by whodeycommish14 on Jan 24, 2012 4:54 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
Simmons was not that studly
for that matter Spikes was very good but he was never really elite. I’m talking top top guys here. Bengals haven’t had one since they traded away Bill Bergey. Look him up, young people.
Attention Mike Brown: One-and-done doesn’t cut it. You will see more empty seats next year if you don’t show the fans you’re trying to win the Super Bowl!
by occams_tiger_teeth on Jan 24, 2012 10:11 PM EST up reply actions
i'd consider takeo elite
over the course of a career. he might not be flashy, but he’s damn consistent. he missed only four tackles over a 3-year span according to PFF. how many linebackers can claim that kind of consistency?
agreed Simmons wasn't special, and Spikes was good, not great.
Although they played behind such a piss-poor D-Line that they never had the chance to freely roam as LB’s should, because the D-Line couldn’t take care of the O-Line for them.
I thought James Francis was pretty darn good.
Odell might have been great, but we’ll never know.
I'm expecting Lawson
to go elsewhere for more dough. He played well enough for a nice raise I expect.
I read somewhere that Rivers has a degenerative condition in his wrist, anyone else heard that?
Anyway, I have had LB on my draft list, even first round if the right guy is there.
But LB isn’t as high on my list given the other needs at dline, oline and CB.
If they could re-sign Lawson, that is probably enough for this season. Otherwise keep an open mind about where Rey plays and see whats available at OLB and ILB.
Mukleroy another blown out achilles.
I’d put him on the shelf till he proves he’s right. Like Hall, he could be PUP or released.
Whoa
What? He suffered another blown Achilles. Put him on the shelf until he proves he’s right? Not sure what you’re saying. Confused as hell.
by whodeycommish14 on Jan 24, 2012 5:18 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roddrick_Muckelroy
Back in August I think.
Guys don’t necessarily come back from torn achilles. Hall may not either.
They have to assume he’s not going to be 100% by training camp. As I recollect, rehab starts with a cast then a boot for 6 months. Muscles are shot by the time jogging is permitted. Its a long rehab.
I thought you were saying
Muckelroy tore his Achilles again. I was really confused there for a second. Yeah I know a couple people who have torn their Achilles and it’s nothing to mess with. However, I can Muckelroy being alright by the time training camp rolls around. Hall is another story. I don’t know what to expect with him. I just hope we address it.
by whodeycommish14 on Jan 24, 2012 5:37 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
Kuechly
I think the Bengals should consider drafting Boston College LB Luke Kuechly if he is available when they pick.
I think we should wait a couple years
to start looking at ML of the future. No way we draft a LB this year in the first
We need a MLB NOW!!!!
Dnt think Rey have the heart. I remember reading that Rey would txt Zimm during the week and say he dnt deserve to start. Thought Rey was the one but know i think he is just a good backup. MLB is like a QB. The Bengals got a top 10 D but just think if the had a MLB with a killer attitude. Just dnt think Rey is really what the Bengals need. I HOPE HE PROVE ME WRONG THIS YEAR.
Need a LB like Willis or Bowman
After watching the 49er’s Bowman and Willis tear it up on Sunday night, I wished the Bengals had a similar LB that can really take control and scare the offense like those two can.
Maualuga
I thought he was much better than his score indicates.
I’m not sure how they calculated him so low.
You're joking, right bud?
by whodeycommish14 on Jan 24, 2012 8:43 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
I doubt he's joking
and it’s kinda funny that Rey was raved about early and on toward the middle of the season. Then all of a sudden he was called out for being horrible. And after the season we hear about him needing ankle surgery. Hmm, wonder if that had anything to do with it.
by Oregonbengalsfan on Jan 24, 2012 9:14 PM EST up reply actions
i thought he did a good job in run defense, and was an upgrade to Dhani wiff Jones in that department. And he was much better pre-ankle injury.
It looks like his overall score was low because his pass defense was terribly low. But i want my MLB to be the fierce Ray Lewis type of run stopper more than somebody who is being wasted in coverage. So i really don’t care if his pass defense score is low, as long as he does a good job stopping the run.
Rey was not an upgrade from Dhani Jones
Dhani was just as bad in pass coverage (age does that to you), but he TACKLED PEOPLE with a lot more reliability than Rey. I seriously think Rey could end up 2nd team next season if Moch or Muckelroy recover enough to provide competition. Hell, Skuta graded out better than Rey. Go figure.
We need an upgrade at Mlb
Dhani Jones lead the team in tackles for a few years and Rey can’t?
by Bigcatdaddy on Jan 25, 2012 10:00 AM EST via Android app reply actions
What's a special teams score?
Just a high school student who lives his ambitions of working for the NFL,
Follow @ProInterviews
Facebook = http://facebook.com/prointerviews/
YouTube = http://youtube.com/user/ProInterviews/

by 































