Cincy Jungle: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Has Kentucky Improved Since the Non-Conference Season?

Bengals re-sign Reggie Kelly

I'm one of many who think it really stinks that we're out of contention with the few quality free agents. This period has turned into a race to sign our own. Now, whether you believe signing our guys back is a sign of success in free agency, to me, is a matter of opinion. Sure, we got both Reggie Kelly and Kenny Watson back, but what makes us think that the team will improve? Is it everyone returning from injury and suspensions going to spell success? I believe that is also a justified argument.

But I'm also one of many that understands the position we're in. Our offense, as kickass as it is, will be around, together, for a couple of seasons. That's continuity at its finest. While the offense is getting second helpings, the defense is getting scraps. But you see that with most teams. It's generally the Super Bowl winning teams that find the perfect balance. It's the greats that continue that into dynasties.

Signing Reggie Kelly is a relief. He's a lockerroom favorite and a great sixth blocker. More importantly, it allows us to go after positions in desperate need of help in the draft. But it's very telling when signing Reggie Kelly, at this point, is the highlight of free agency. That's not a slam against Kelly; rather the team's inability to find ways to free up money.

Kelly to return [Bengals.com]

0 recs  |  Comment 1 comment

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

re:
In one of his interviews with Geoff Hobson, Coach Lewis sounded like a guy soured by experience with free agents.  Hobson quotes Lewis:
"People continue to point out the teams that (spend) in free agency win less games," he said. "It takes chemistry. It's people working together. It takes time. When we get a guy off another team, invariably there comes that adverse time within the game that he reverts back to other things that he knows from another place and another time. That's not the reaction you need at that critical moment.

"The answer is to always try and reserve some of your own players and continue to progress with guys in the draft," Lewis said. "Continue to let them mature and develop as football players in the NFL. They're trained in your system, they're trained your way and that's the way teams continue to get better."

Is this insight learned from four years of experience?; or, rather, adherence to a sterile theory?; or just smoke to conceal miserly business decisions not to spend big $$$ this year on FAs?  Look at some of Lewis's FA signings and decide for yourself; you'd know much better than I which signings since `03 came with fanfare, confetti and balloons, and which were quiet deals involving role players.  Here's a partial list:  Kevin Hardy; Frank Chamberlin, John Thornton; Reggie Kelly; Tory James,  Nate Webster, Bobbie Williams, Brian Robinson; Antonio Chatman; Rashad Jeanty; Marcus Wilkins; and Dexter Jackson.  

In general, Lewis has used FAs mainly to build the D-line and for D-backs (though he's begun to use high draft picks on the D-backs) and TEs.   But the D-line is not one of the better ones in the league, and the fix of the secondary proved to be temporary and didn't last.  He had big FA linebacker signing in `03 and `04, and those didn't work out too well.  So I tend to think he's speaking from experience when he downplays the ability of free agency to build the sort of team he wants.  I take him at his word that he believes it takes time, it takes chemistry, and that free agents are unlikely to make an immediate good impact.  That may or may not be true, but he believes it.

I think the Bengals could have freed up money for free agent signings had they wanted to; but they didn't want to.  What players should they have signed?  Porter?  As a LB or DE, because the Bengals don't line up in a 3 - 4?  And Mark Maske of the Washington Post said today that Porter's game is deteriorating, that he talks a much better game than he produces on the field.  Maybe Lewis had the same opinion.  Nate Clements?  I doubt the Bengals could have outbid SF.  Also, Lewis has warned O'Neal to improve his play and his practice ethic; but he's not yet ready to cut or bench him; he'll give him one more chance to improve his play.  As a result, I think Lewis is more willing to draft a cornerback and pressure O'Neal that way, a young guy ready to take his job; rather than make a big FA signing that puts either O'Neal or Joseph immediately on the bench.  How `bout LB, e.g., London Fletcher?  I think Lewis is hoping to start Thurman, Brooks and Jeanty next season; that, together with his experience with Hardy, Chamberlin and Webster, suggests he won't spend big money on an expensive LB.  I think he's willing to commit to his young LBs, to sink or swim with them.  Besides, how many young, fast, quick, aggressive LBs, experienced in a 4 - 3 defense, are on the market, anyway?  If he'd wanted a LB longer on experience than the attributes he wants, he wouldn't have cut Simmons.  There's a message in that Simmons move.  

Perhaps it's because I've seen the annual Redskin FA extravaganzas that I'm so ready to cheer Lewis's "do nothing" approach.  Indeed, the Washington Post is cheering the Redskins' "restraint" this year.  A mega-deal to a soon-to-be 32 year old LB, and a smaller deal to Loveboat Smoot is what passes for restraint these days in the nation's capital.

by etabby on Mar 6, 2007 11:07 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Cincinnati Bengals.
Start posting about the Bengals »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Tiger_joe_small
Prospect Watch: Demaryius Thomas
Small
Bengal 2010 Draft
Small
What Might Ruin the NFL Next Year
Palmer_small
Pointless debate of the week
Tiger_joe_small
Prospect Watch: Brandon Graham
Tiger_joe_small
Andre Caldwell vs Rookie WR
Tiger_joe_small
Bengals and Senior Bowl
C1fc33125ca7_small
Bengals Mock Draft
Helmet_small
Ocho Cinco our new kicker? seriously
Helmet_small
Maualuga arrested!!!! Man 2010 starting off bad!!!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Mocking The Draft
Morgan Burnett NFL Draft scouting report
The Phinsider
A quick look at free agent tight ends
Mocking The Draft
A case for Sam Bradford going first overall

Managers

Atari_small Kirkendall

Twitter_profile_pic_small A Pragmatic Bengals Fan

Authors

Small Vman in Germany

Oso-bengalslogo-animation_small Jay McDonnell

Henry152_small IFChris

Huber090426_440_small jsl413

Infighting_small Mojokong