clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Can Ryan Tannehill win in a shootout with Joe Burrow?

If Bengals-Titans is a high-scoring affair, can the Tennessee quarterback do his part?

Syndication: The Enquirer Kareem Elgazzar/The Enquirer / USA TODAY NETWORK

Joe Burrow.

Those two words, in my mind, explain—to a large degree—how the Bengals finally won a playoff game.

Don’t believe me?

Let’s look at some stats.

Burrow had one of the very best starts to a postseason in the last thirty years by completing at least 70% of his passes and posting a QB rating of over 100, one of only three quarterbacks to do so. He joined Drew Brees and Kurt Warner. Brees, of course, didn’t make the postseason until his fourth year and Warner was 28 years old when he made his playoff debut.

Further, Burrow has already surpassed every Bengals quarterback since Boomer Esiason in terms of playoff passing touchdowns.

And in terms of advanced analytics, Burrow is heads-and-shoulders above the performances of his predecessor, Andy Dalton, both in Pro Football Focus grades and in expected points added (EPA):

Thus, the reality is that if the Bengals really want a chance at the AFC Championship, it will, again, be Burrow and the high-flying passing attack that gives them the best chance.

But if Derrick Henry is limited and the Tennessee Titans are forced to throw early and often, can Ryan Tannehill keep up with Burrow?

So far, Tannehill has not exactly broken passing records in his playoff games. He’s been active for two postseasons, last year and the year before. In four postseason games, though, he’s only topped 200 yards once (209 against in a loss against the Kansas City Chiefs). In fact, in the two wins for which he was the signal caller, Tannehill didn’t even top 100 yards or 15 pass attempts. Could all that change? Maybe. But it isn’t likely.

We spoke with former Titan Denard Walker and asked him if Tannehill can win a shootout with Burrow despite a mediocre regular season. Walker pointed out that the Titans quarterback “hasn’t had all of his pieces all season.” Receiver A.J. Brown has missed four games and future Hall of Famer Julio Jones has missed seven games.

Walker explained that Tannehill’s role is, indeed, to manage the game. And that should be easier now that his receivers are healthy. “If you don’t have your Pro Bowl receiver from last year, A.J., if you don’t have the Waffle House, Julio Jones, and then your high man was really your fourth receiver coming into the season, I don’t care what quarterback you have, it’s going to be hard to win or put up numbers.”

You can watch the entire preview below:

You can also listen on iTunes or using the player below:

Win free Bengals tickets and signed merch by playing Bengals Picks for free here: