clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

NFL Playoffs 2014: Cincinnati Bengals eliminated in 26-10 loss to the Indianapolis Colts

The Cincinnati Bengals are done after losing to the Indianapolis Colts 26-10. This is the fourth straight year that they've been eliminated during the first round of the 2014 NFL playoffs.

Brian Spurlock-USA TODAY Sports

I want to be angry.

This is the fourth consecutive year that the Bengals have been bounced from the postseason in the first round, and the fifth time in the last six years -- one-and-done (Jets), one-and-done (Texans), one-and-done (Texans), one-and-done (Chargers), one-and-done (Colts). Perhaps the Bengals need to run the gauntlet of every AFC team before claiming that elusive first postseason win since Jan. 6, 1991.

Yet let's face facts... this is who the Cincinnati Bengals are and all they're capable of. If you're satisfied to be a participant in the postseason, this team is for you. If you want something more, than I'm not sure what can be offered for resolution. It's almost like a television show that you love to hate but the episodes, once exciting and brimming with anticipation, spin in the mud of boredom with "see it once, seen 'em all" aggravation.

I want to be angry.

I should be angry.

Cincinnati's pass rush against a patchwork offensive line was shockingly embarrassing, even with weighted contracts signed by several on the defensive line, while the team insists on relying on a handful of undrafted free agents at linebacker and aging first-rounders in the secondary. Eventually the Bengals lost Rey Maualuga to a hamstring Sunday, who was replaced by rookie Marquis Flowers, who himself was fighting through an ankle injury. Cornerback Dre Kirkpatrick also had an ankle issue but eventually returned, and then left again.

The Bengals offense, without wide receiver A.J. Green and tight end Jermaine Gresham, had nothing for the Indianapolis Colts. Some of us will excuse Cincinnati's offense, which is fine. Unfortunately the NFL isn't going to wait on injured players to get healthy to stage another rematch.

The Bengals have scored points of 17, 10, 13, 10, and 10 points in the last five playoff games.

A loss is a loss... no matter how many propositions you want to excuse for the Bengals. On the other hand, there is truth to it as well. They also didn't have wide receiver Marvin Jones and Tyler Eifert all season. Green and Gresham were gone after their injuries against the Steelers. Andy Dalton is as bland as a manilla folder that collapses against the face of adversity, but we're not blaming him for much Sunday.

Rightfully, the Colts focused on Jeremy Hill, aware that the ordinary Hue Jackson wouldn't draw up anything creative while restricted by the dictation of the game's flow and the excuses of missing stars. Eventually, Hill would make sporadic second half appearance.

I should be angry.

I am angry.

Yet, I'm shocked and by extension, not really that angry. I expected this. For as much as we want to dictate ridiculous amounts of faith in a team that doesn't deserve it, Cincinnati folds in pressure situations.

That continues to be the narrative.

Sure Cincinnati defeated Peyton Manning and the Denver Broncos during Week 16 on Monday Night Football. That was an accomplishment, but more of an aberration, rather than some redefining moment that we had hoped for. With an opportunity to win the AFC North last week, they are defeated on Sunday Night Football thanks to an A.J. Green fumble when the Bengals were piecing together a game-winning drive.

Pressure. Adversity. Collapse.

This is who they are.


Predictably, the Cincinnati Bengals featured Michael Strahan-sized gaps in coverage while offering little resistance against the run. Indianapolis opened the afternoon with an impressive 71-yard touchdown drive that began on their own 29-yard line. Within nine plays and nearly four minutes, the Colts took a 7-0 lead on Dan Herron's two-yard touchdown drive.

Each exchanged punts from Pro Bowl punters before Cincinnati's offense resumed from their own 26-yard line with 5:54 remaining in the first. Eventually, with help from a Jeremy Hill 18-yard run to the Colts, the Bengals had third and four from the Colts 31-yard line with 3:06 remaining. Dalton hit Rex Burkhead, who gained 26 yards to the Colts five-yard line.

Two plays later, Jeremy Hill jumped into the endzone to tie the game at 7-7 with 1:28 remaining in the first.


Indianapolis opened their ensuing possession with 1:28 remaining in the first from their own nine-yard line. With relative ease against an injured Bengals defense, the Colts navigated downfield until they reach the Bengals 20-yard line. Needing 10 yards to convert the third down, Andrew Luck instead targeted Reggie Wayne in the back of the endzone, Cornerback Dre Kirkpatrick forced the incomplete pass.

With 10:12 remaining in the second, Andrew Luck found Hakeem Nicks on a 45-yard completion... the receiver turned around and jumped to haul in the football while George Iloka kept his back turned. Unable to generate another first down, Adam Vinatieri extended Indianapolis' lead 13-7 with 8:34 remaining in the second.


With two minutes remaining in the second quarter, the Colts had second and 18 at their own 48-yard line -- Margus Hunt sacked Andrew Luck, which allowed the clock to reach the two minute warning.

Andrew Luck dumped off to Herron, who avoided a handful of tackles down the left sidelines. Darqueze Dennard, coming from behind near the Bengals 35-yard line, tomahawk chopped the football away from Herron. The football was recovered by Reggie Nelson.

Cincinnati reached the Colts 39-yard line where Mike Nugent crushed a franchise-setting 57-yard field goal with 15 seconds remaining in the first half.


The Cincinnati Bengals and Indianapolis Colts have released their respective inactive lists and, as we approached the deadline Sunday's deadline, we had a certain understanding on who would be available.

Wide receivers A.J. Green (concussion) and James Wright (knee) were already declared out by Sunday morning -- Green was announced on Saturday, reportedly after a visit with an independent specialist. Green suffered a concussion with four minutes remaining against the Pittsburgh Steelers last week. Wright hasn't played since week 13 against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers with a knee, though he worked with the wide receivers during pregame work.

Gresham suffered a back injury against the Steelers and sat during practice on Wednesday and Thursday with limited work on Friday. Observers noted that Gresham didn't look good during pregame workouts and joined Green and Wright on the team's inactive list.

Brandon Tate will replace Green as the starting wide receiver opposite of Mohamed Sanu and Kevin Brock will replace Jermaine Gresham as the starting tight end.

WR A.J. Green OL Hugh Thornton
TE Jermaine Gresham OL A.Q. Shipley
DT Devon Still OL Xavier Nixon
WR James Wright DL Zach Kerr
QB AJ McCarron LB Henoc Muamba
CB Chris Lewis-Harris CB Sheldon Price
OT Tanner Hawkinson CB Jalil Brown


WR James Wright Concussion DNP DNP DNP OUT
WR A.J. Green Concussion DNP LP DNP DOUBTFUL
TE Jermaine Gresham Back DNP DNP LP Questionable
RB Cedric Peerman Concussion DNP LP LP Questionable
OT Andrew Whitworth Vet. -- DNP -- --
CB Leon Hall Vet. DNP -- -- --
G Hugh Thornton Shoulder DNP DNP DNP OUT
RB Trent Richardson Illness -- -- DNP Questionable
WR Joshua Cribbs NIR DNP FP FP Probable
LB Erik Walden Knee LP FP FP Probable
WR Reggie Wayne Groin LP FP DNP Probable
LB Bjoern Werner Shoulder LP FP FP Probable
TE Dwayne Allen Knee FP FP FP Probable
LB Jerrell Freeman Hamstring FP FP FP Probable
G Joe Reitz Ankle FP FP FP Probable

DNP - Did Not Participate
LP - Limited Participation
FP - Full Participation

Game Status
Out = Player will not play
Doubtful = 25% chance a player will play
Questionable = 50% chance a player will play
Probable = 75% chance a player will play
(-) = Not Listed - No game status available