clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Does Shayne Graham retirement contract point to a Bengals culture change?

New, comments

The Bengals and Shayne Graham joined together and came up with a great way to honor the former kicker. Does this mean more of these types of contracts will be coming? Why hasn’t the front office done more of this with other former Bengals greats?

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

For years, the Cincinnati Bengals have had the reputation of keeping their fans and many former players at an arm’s length. Many are ready to point directly at owner Mike Brown for the franchise’s mindset in this respect, but the truth is that even his iconic father, Paul Brown, exuded this same attitude while in charge of both the Browns and the Bengals.

In recent years, the team has attempted to begin to make amends in this regard, whether it’s in their creation of fan-centric events or honoring past greats at games, there seems to be a bit of a changing of the guard. The most recent example of this possibility came with this week’s signing of Shayne Graham to a one-day contract to officially retire as a Bengal.

This P.R.-friendly move led us to ask more questions on this week’s Orange and Black Insider. Is this a baby-step toward the Bengals finally looking to retire jersey numbers of past greats? Is a Ring of Honor finally around the corner? Why haven’t other past greats, be it in the Marvin Lewis era or before, been given the same kind of recognition?

We began to wonder if this is yet another symptom of the favoritism we have seen over the years from Lewis and the Brown family. For Lewis, one of his detrimental tendencies has been to make talented youngsters bide their time because “they don’t practice the right way” and/or “don’t know how to be a pro”. Graham was a guy who was always in Lewis’ favor from 2003-2009, despite fan criticism.

Now, this isn’t to say that Graham isn’t deserving of this honor, because he most definitely is. Even though some big misses spring to the cynical fan base’s mind, he also made a large amount of big ones in his seven-year Bengals career. Aside from his on-field contributions, Graham was also a big figure in The Queen City with many charitable contributions.

So, the issues we had with this contract isn’t with Graham, the player. Why hasn’t the team reached out in similar fashions to guys like Chad Johnson, Willie Anderson, Bobbie Williams and so many others? Why, when the team finally makes a gesture that resembles an actual professional football franchise, won’t they let the flood gates open and embrace other greats?

Then again, are we being too hard on the Bengals? For those of us who have followed this team and experienced high levels of frustration and devastation, it’s easy to nitpick the club, even when they finally do things the right way. It’s just the way of the Bengals fan, right?

Regardless, it will be interesting to see if the team ends up taking this gesture to the next level. If the power shift to the triumvirate of Lewis, Duke Tobin and Katie Blackburn is truly ushering changes, more of these contracts and a Ring of Honor should be forthcoming.

We are live every week on our YouTube channel and here at Cincy Jungle as we record the program. The Orange and Black Insider staff also answers fan questions regularly, so you can submit them there or on our other media platforms. If you’re unable to catch the show live, you can download our content here at CJ and YouTube, or at our SoundCloud channel and on iTunes. We’re also reachable on Twitter @BengalsOBI and via email at theobinisder@gmail.com. Subscribe today!